Encounter 123 – July 24, 2020

For some moments our age averaged about 45… Four participants over 65, and four under 25… In other words, we had some young in our midst!
Want to meet? Let’s, but today in English, which is a great excuse for my inaccuracies…
Shmulik shows how we introduce ourselves by mentioning his own name, place of residence and his Gaza awareness.
Gal, on the younger side of our age-mean, knew that Gaza is where rockets and bombs are launched at Israel… After meeting Fuad, she learned much about life there, but Gaza still frightens her.
Madsen (or “Madi”, her nickname) came from California. She is learning a lot about this place and situation. Gaza for her is a “black box” which she is trying to decipher. She says that most of the people she knows in Israel don’t know anything about Gaza. They think it’s a state. She fears the lack of knowledge about people suffering there.
Dor, who “built” our circle with us two weeks ago, has come back to Migdalor faster than she intended… She was born to Israelis in America, but spent all her childhood and youth vacations among her grandparents in Kibbutz Zikim and at Netiv Ha-Asara. Still it took her many years to understand the meaning of life in our area. She is conscious of the hardships because of driving Palestinian patients to hospitals in Israel. It’s a small conduit of information.
Rami mentions the speed at which we forget our feelings about Gaza and sink back into our everyday business. That is why we light a small “light” at Migdalor (Hebrew for lighthouse) every week. He emphasizes that a short while free of missiles from Gaza is “enough” for everyone here to forget Gaza and its people.
Fuad says that in Gaza one must actually fight for their health, it’s not accessible. Migdalor is the way to remember home. People are frustrated with the problems in Gaza that are only getting worse. People in Gaza are committing suicide. Unemployment and lockdown is frustrating and makes them desperate. One of the suicides was actually seeking help, and no one offered to help. When Fuad sees people living well and right next to them people hardly making it, he asks why it has to be this way.
Hayuta sees Gaza from her home. She tells Fuad that the fact that Israel has made it possible for him to come here to study is a miracle as far as she is concerned. Huyuta sees Gaza from her home but does not really know how hard life is over there.
Mark finds himself on the spectrum between understanding himself and understanding his environment. He is worried about what is going to happen to the world soon. Yesterday he finished preparing subtitles for someone foretelling the end of the world… These are the problems he is concerned about, the bigger picture. Gaza is the near example of the world’s decline environmentally. He says it’s not respectable to come here and not talk about Gaza, but he has a hard time deciding what is more important at the moment. Specifically Gaza with all of its different problems, or the global ecological catastrophe. He is filled with frustration.
Rami says that being here is being ‘active’. He tells Fuad that in order to meet him here, at Migdalor, it was worth coming here every week for 2 years and 4 months…
Malki has been in the are for 5 years already. For her Migdalor is a point of sanity. So many bad things are taking place around us, and coming here gives her deeper breath and calm, so she is a regular. To remain sane… Rami says that our Roni represents the meaning of Migdalor with her activity! She is the light that shines for those who need help in Gaza, and toward which they navigate! He asks Roni how not to forget…
Roni introduces herself and her activity, her life history in the region, and her mission in Egypt. When she was young she lived in Sinai, and was not interested in the issue of the Occupied Territories… Roni does not see herself belonging anywhere else, but sees Palestinians the same way. She asks what is to be done with the feeling of belonging of the two peoples to the same place. She needs a partner on the other side who belives like her that both belong here. And she has found them! At any given moment in her life she is in touch or somehow busy with something related to Gaza. When solution will come, both sides need to discuss it and agree. The situation right now is a lose-lose one…
Fuad wants to add something: his family came from a village that was demolished and its inhabitants expelled. For him, that village is his grandfather’s home. And the prickly-pears that still stand there are witness to it.
Roni says that her family too experienced expulsion and refugee-dom and had to leave its home and homeland, so she definitely understands the Palestinians’ refugee sense. She tells Fuad that the place he feels as his ‘home’ should become a real home.
Mark too speaks of his family’s ‘wanderings’, and that he always felt that Israel is his home. England, where he was born, was not home. But every narrative should be listened to and the problems must be solved together.
Shmulik says that after the 1967 war, many refugees came to visit the area of Kibbutz Zikim and Karmiya, where their villages had been and from which they were expelled in the 1948 war. For us, of Ha-Shomer Ha-Tzair it was a kind of a shock! (He didn’t say why…) Many families came with the keys of their home as a token of memory.
Rami notices that the dominant word in the circle is ‘memory’. He suggests we speak about the link between ‘home’ and ‘memory’.
Salah, grandson of the famous Sheikh Sliman Al-Huzail, says that the State of Israel belongs to us all and we should concentrate on the present.
Madsen came to Israel on the “Birthright” project. She wanted to know more about Judaism and Israel. From the moment she arrived she was told that this was her home. The history of this land belongs to us, they said. She wanted that this is indeed home, just as some of her friends wanted to move and live in Israel. Madsen was disappointed. She did not manage to feel that she belonged, even after 10 days… She says she could “decide” to feel this way. There are two groups here, she says, but only one of them has the right to say that this is its home. If she, born in the US, has the right to build her home here, then certainly Fuad should have the same right.
Dor says that her grandfather from Nativ Ha-Asara did not feel for a moment that this was not his own place. When he left the older (settlement) of Nativ Ha-Asara in the Sinai, he literally wept. He was born in Iraq. He felt that the settlement was his home. Home is something one creates and builds.
Malki relates to what Madsen said, that one needs to be free to choose one’s home. Destiny had decided on her own birth place and faith. In Israel she feels at home anywhere she lives. She does not believe she could feel that way anywhere else. She has childhood memories from Tel Aviv. There is a kind of nostalgia any time she comes there.
Fuad enjoys listening. He shows the Hebrew he’s learned! He says that if you are Palestinian, you have a document from the Palestinian Authority. This is what unites them, a document that does not even mention a state but only an “authority”. He spent a lot of time with his grandparents as a child. Bedtime stories about the village from which they were expelled. They wanted Fuad to realize that where they are now is not home. Home is in that village… For him home is where family is. His own family is scattered in several places around the world. But is every such a place, home?
Roni says she has been listening to everyone and noticed that each person has their own definition for home. She thinks it’s something strong, internal. There is a difference between her family home in England, and here. She feels divided between England and Israel.
Shmulik shares with us his insight from reading Meron Benbenisti’s book Dream of the White Sabra, where the author simply defines himself as ‘native’.
Mark tells us about his father who escaped South Africa. He himself did not like their home in England. His family has known expulsions, and he wished to build a safe home for his children so he came here…
Hayuta, in the past, needed to feel a real physical sense of home. Now she feels more balanced between the physical and the symbolic home.
Manal says she likes to come to Migdalor to listen. She has never had such an experience and wishes to go on coming. Her own life, as a girl, was better than it is now because she was not at all busy with the notion of home. They simply lived there… Now there is more alienation when they have a built-up house.
Salah thinks we should speak about the history of the Jews (the Bible…) which is also a kind of claim to the land.
Ye’ela says that the area is her childhood landscape more than her physical home.
Finally we spoke a bit about the intention to host a Palestinian member of the Committee for Interaction with Israeli Society, and wondered whether it would be recorded by the media. There were opinions in different directions. Then we left.
Present were: Salah, Oded, Gal, Madsen, Dor, Malki, Fuad, Roni, Mark, Hayuta, Manal, Rami, Shmulik, Ye’ela, Shani, Negev (grandson).
Wrote: Oded

Encounter 122 – July 17, 2020

While Shmulik and I lay out a circle of chairs and make the first round of coffee, here come Salah and Manal – travelers. They are invited to have a seat, and Salah asks us about ourselves and the old sulfur plant nearby.
In the meantime, more members of the Migdalor circle arrive and we begin our introduction circle:
Salah works on gardening projects (in Lahav, Mishmar Ha-Negev and other localities). He “goes back” to Biblical times and wonders about our origins and his. He concludes that “no matter what religion we ascribe, ‘proper behavior precedes the Toreah’. His father was the first Bedouin to have served in the Israeli army. He is very angry at the Israeli authorities for not letting him build, and only demolish homes, and hates the Gazans for frightening his kids when they hear the bombing sirens. He uses harsh hateful language that raises a debate and reactions to his spiteful statements about Gaza.
Manal does not elaborate beyond introducing herself, but is rather resentful of her partner’s words… Salah likes to quote the Bible. His uncle Taleb was the deputy governor of Gaza.
Roni speaks of her activity for Gazan rights. Every day all day she is busy processing different applications and requests for help of people locked up in Gaza. Some of them call her “our mother”. Roni says that her 10-year old grandchild was alone when a siren went off, was scared and cried, and when his mom came and he calmed down, he told her, “perhaps we should listen to grandma?”…
Salah and Manal take their leave, Manal is moved and promises to be back.
Uri asks about Covid 19 in Gaza. Jaber emphasizes and discipline and strict orders given by Hamas that have kept the disease rates low. A discussion begins about public discipline, from coping with pandemics to the point of dictatorship. Rami raises the issue of a mental shift (continued from last week…) and asks us to relate to the claim that totalitarianism is not necessarily bad and perhaps such a regime is better at coping with a pandemic crisis… Nomika suggests a “topic” to think and speak about: a personal event that has affected her frame of mind. She says her life in the town of Sderot, as a kibbutznik, has made her livein harmony with identities other than hers and to examine the meaning of ‘prejudice’.
A few years ago, at a European airport, Uri met a Syrian family. When introducing himself as an Israeli, the Syrian man hugged him warmly and told him how they envy Israelis who live under more freedom. “Back then I was a leftie, not right-wing as I am today”, says Uri. Nowadays if he hears Arabic being spoken near him in Israel, he is immediately on “enemy” alert.
Jaber says that the authorities in the Arab countries do not reflect what their peoples think. He once sat with a Moroccan Arab who said that his enemy was the Israeli, not the Jew. He has met a Jew married to a Muslim woman and she took the trouble to save him Kosher food for Passover. He was very moved.
Shmulik responds to the challenge raised by Rami, and says that many non-dictatorial states have overcome the Corona pandemic. He speaks about Meron Benbenisti whose book “The Dream of the White Sabra” he is now reading, and identifies himself as undergoing a process of “the biography of disillusion” that the author describes in the book. In the past Shmulik met Nathan Yellin Mor, and Uzi Ornan – the “Canaanite” brother of poet Yonatan Ratosh – who had both experienced a mental shift. The consciousness he has reached brings him to our circle here, which is a political act as far as he is concerned. Canaanite for him is first and foremost language, then landscape, space. He met a tour guide from (settler-colonist) Etzyon Bloc who was travelling with a book by Rachel Yanait Ben Zvi (wife of Israel’s 2nd president). Shmulik himself was travelling with the book “Khirbet Hiz’a” by S. Yizhar (a n Israeli book containing acknowledgment of the 1948 Nakba that was rather ostracized when it was published in the 1950s). They both reached the same conclusion: the country is for everyone, both from the right and from the left.
Uri says that defining left and right is a complicated business.
Rami says that the need to define makes for distance. When he lived in Mitzpe Ramon it took him years to connect to the “street” where he lived. Once he was hiking with a friend to the spring. They thought they would be alone… When people came, Rami and his friend challenged themselves and tried to set their ‘prejudices’ about those people. They were wrong again and again… Every person interests him as a person. He is “practicing” his ability not to define and have prior opinion about a certain person.
Roni speaks of the regime issue. Lately she been living between democracy that enables opinions, and their limitation. But if the majority has chosen, does she have a right to oppose their choice? A ruler needs to show ‘maturity’ and understand that he is also responsible for those who did not vote for him. She recalls going to conference in the US. When she left Israel, Peres was the elected Prime Minister, and when she arrived at the US, Bibi was in power. At the conference she spoke of this turnover and said that Bibi is responsible for her too, for Roni, although she did not vote for him. My own opinion, says Roni, is irrelevant if I don’t consider the other side.
Jaber says that most of us “follow”, don’t express independent opoinions. The ruling power directs us and everyone follows. People need at least to listen to one another even if the regime defines them as enemies.
Nahshi answers Uri about “problematic” definitions of left and right. This definition is political and does not at all cover economic definition and others. Left-wing, by definition, encourages study, discussion, asking questions. The right-wing adheres to absolute truths. Managing the Corona pandemic dictatorially does not “solve” anything but creates a powder keg that activates even “followers”.
Nomika grew up in a liberal home but still was not aware of the tremendous crisis that befell Palestinians in 1948. In a Palestinian-Israeli school project, the Palestinian children drew the country outline and wrote in it “Palestine”, the Jewish children drew the same map and wrote “Israel”. Nomike could hardly believe she was totally “erased” on the Palestinian map.
That’s it for today. We remind everyone that if conditions are right, we will meet on August 7 with a Palestinian representative of the Committee for Interaction with Israeli society.
Participants: Salah, Manal, Rami, Shmulik, Roni, Jaber, Nahshi, Limor, Oded, Nomika, Uri, Tomer.
Wrote: Oded

Encounter 121 – July 10, 2020

So we got together, as Yossi Sarid (well-known left-wing politician, publicist and writer, now deceased) used to say.
The circle today was held in several rounds. The first included Shmulik, Oded, Rami, Roni and Hayuta. We began by warming up personally and joking about one another from the sheer pleasure of meeting.
Rami began by telling about work he has been doing in the Eilot region. Following this work he has been pondering the question whether the value of work has totally vanished from our present mental world.
Each of the participants voiced their opinion on the subject:
Shmulik claimed that ever since the kibbutz abandoned the idea of its members doing all the work, labor in general has become devalued, probably in conjunction with the general collapse of the communal kibbutz idea.
Rami wonders about that change and gave for example one of the main figures of kibbutz Be’eri who knew how to harness people to work at the kibbutz’ printing press, and give it and them meaning through their work.
Hayuta stated that any human interaction that has one going out from the self to the collective – be it as it may – means work.
The circle’s second round began when Mark, Malki, Uzi and Bella joined us. Rami raised the issue of annexation and our response to the possibility of annexing the Gaza Strip.
Mark claimed that annexation from a position of superiority without any dialogue is unacceptable.
Shmulik referred to the semantics of the word ‘annexation’. He thinks that the word (sipuach in Hebrew) connotes the minimization of the annexed people to a kind of marginalized superfluity. This, in his opinion, contradicts the idea of equality of human beings be they who they may. Shmulik raised the idea of egalitarian annexation according to the Swiss canton model.
Rami brought up the hypothetical possibility based on historical examples of annexations that were beneficial to the annexed population. Such as Britain’s control of Israel during the British Mandate {1919-1948)/
Hayuta deliberated between loyalty to the value of human equality as a supreme value, and an extreme following of this value resulting in leaving the situation unresolved
Oded said that his resolute opinions about human equality and other matters have not in been in vogue for many years now. “I am used to this, I know that I cannot be on the winning side…”
Roni believes in dialogue with the Gazans.
So does Malki.
Bella expressed her fear of losing her (Jewish-Israeli) identity if the Gazans become an inseparatble part of the State of Israel.
Uzi supports parts of the Trump plan. He thinks Gaza should be helped as much as possible but remain outside Israel’s borders and control. Our power assures our survival and protects our neighbors, especially the Palestinian and the Jordanians. He also thinks that the powerful and victorious are responsible for the weak and vanquished…
At the close of these rounds, Mark expressed the idea of publishing a written text about various issues. Rami focused the Gaza matter. We all welcomed the initiative. Rami added that Mark would share it with others. Whatever is done alone, is not done – he remarked.
Mark concluded the circle by telling a painful personal story about accompanying an ill Palestinian to the checkpoint post-surgery.
Shabat Shalom!
Written by Hayuta

encouner 120 – July 3, 2020

Most of the participants today are our “regulars”. Two new ones joined us for the first time. One of them does not speak Hebrew so today’s circle took place partly in English and partly in Hebrew, translated into English.
For the sake of our new guests, we spoke about ourselves and our motivation to gather every Friday since mid-March, 2018.
Rami spoke of his childhood recollections, experiencing Gaza first as a threat. After the 1967 war, it became a routine of shared life and ended up with various initiatives. He spoke of his belief in a shared space and touched upon the reasons that led him to initiate “Migdalor” (lighthouse).
Shmulik came to this space in 1964, and ever since he has worked with cattle, worked with Gazan workers, contractors and merchants for many years. Like Rami, he too believes in shared space.
Hanan brings hope and meets hope at the circle. He draws strength from it. Hanan feels that the participants speak sincerely, do not fake it and are not afraid to express their feelings. He is exposed to new knowledge at every single meeting, trying to overcome the despair that reality holds, and bringing strength and optimism.
Mark spoke in English and here’s what I gathered: Over half his life he has already lived here in Israel. He is not optimistic, and thinks he is not doing enough for Gaza. At times he feels that the language we use about reality in Gaza is not strong enough. He hopes a peace movement will arise, aspiring for equality for all, and thinks that we Israelis must change ourselves, and not that Palestinians can change us.
For Jaber, living in an unrecognized village in the Negev under touch conditions, coming to the circle every Friday means reminding himself that there are people who suffer more. Gaza for him is also family, and he feels it his human duty not to forget the suffering that Gazans are living with.
Oded speaks of the moral duty to see and hear the hardships that our neighbors in Gaza are undergoing, and especially when we, their neighbors, enjoy far better conditions of life and are to a great extent responsible for their dire situation.
Ghadir comes from Beer Sheva. She was born in Acre and recalls frequent visits to Gaza in her childhood. She thinks Arab citizens of Israel should be the bridge that connects their fellow Palestinians and the Jewish Israelis. Everyone must understand that there are other people living in this space, and not just think of their own people.
Dor was born in L.A. to Israeli parents. She has grandparents in Kibbutz Zikim, as well as in Netiv Ha-Asara. As a child she came on frequent visits and remembers the sabra fruit (prickly pear) and working in the greenhouses with her grandfather. In the US she studied for her BA at UC Berkeley, and came to further her studies in Israel at the institute for environmental studies where she is now. In Berkeley she learned about indigenous struggles worldwide, and felt that in order to get to know the local conflict better, she should come back and check her own origins. “Generating change in the world necessitates self-examination”, she says. During her visits here as a child she saw her grandfather speaking Arabic with the workers in the greenhouses and couldn’t understand why there is so much hostility and victimhood. When she left home and went to college she was exposed to other sides and complexities of the conflict, not only on the Israeli side but on the Palestinianone as well. It’s not hope that drives her, but rather tradition and values that necessitate attention to what is going on here. She is often challenged by her Israeli cousins and accused for “not being from here”… So she feels a tremendous need to learn about “Israeli-ness” without giving up her “American-ness”, and bridge her own dual identity when discussing the conflict.
Dina, who has lived in the area over 40 years now, feels it is important not to be indifferent to the situation. She is peeved by the fact that many people don’t feel a need to do something to change it for the better! She hopes that in spite of all the difficulties and the dim horizon, voices like ours will grow. Coming to the circle is a bonus for learning something new that can be contributed by every person.
Marin from Azerbaijan (for who we spoke English…) thinks it is important for people who suffer to know that someone is thinking about them. He too, like Dor, studies in Israel at the institute of environmental and nature studies. Azerbaijan for him is everything – home, family, memories, depth of feelings.
Malki who has lived in Gvulot for the past five years is physically gloser to Gaza. She comes with despair and frustration, not hope. The leaderships are not providing any reasons for optimism. Living in our region does not enable one to ignore this, and she comes here to meet good people who give her hope and goes home feeling better. The circle sows a seed and is certain of its success. Gaza for her does not mean memories and experiences, but something that needs to be solved. She emphasizes, saying “Migdal-or” (“or” in Hebrew means light…)
Rami summarizes, saying that the fact that a place exists which is sought after to be helped – this in itself is a worthy cause. Whoever is in the midst of a storm, and knows there is a light to be aspired to, feels he can continue and believe and reach that light. Rami emphasizes our commitment to go on and define our circle with the purpose of raising “Gaza awareness”!
Participants: Ghadir, Dor, Dina, Marin, Malki, Rami, Shmulik, Hanan, Mark, Jaber, Oded.
Wrote: Oded

Encounter no. 119 – June 26, 2020

Another Friday, another meeting.
Hayuta opens, saying that indeed Gaza is the reason for our coming together, but she is not in contact with Gazans so she is here mainly to support the supporters…
Shmulik sits here because of the human commitment and awareness of the goings-on in Gaza and the people he knew there. He speaks about his visits in Hizma with Faisal. Unfortunately, his contact with Gaza has lately been broken…
Malki (like Hayuta) has no historical ties with Gaza. In her opinion no one in the country is privileged to do nothing. When a security event (terrorist attack? Military operation?) begins, she is concerned, but on second thought, she realizes that to a certain extent they (Palestinians) need to remind Israel at times that it has locked them in, and to remind the world that they are here (the world has an easy time forgetting all about them…). Malki feels good about this social encounter. She understands that the situation there (in Gaza) is abnormal.
Dina connects with the circle. The idea “speaks” to her. The Gaza issue is urgent. Can more be done about it? Beyond talking in a circle… There is a gap between the situation and our possibilities to do something about it. She didn’t know about the “young committee” in Gaza. She admits that she should come out of her zone and do more. Last week she learned much about the Bedouins through the circle.
Hayuta updates Dina about our communication history with the Gazan group, our disconnection from them and our duty to keep silent. Dina speaks about a window of opportunity that came up a few years ago for her to create ties with Yemen. She participated in a course for tour guides in Yemen but it was closed because the Israelis talked too much… It’s a miss. One needs to know when to keep silent…
Nahshi tells us he used to work, was acquainted with and met Gazans. Ever since Israel’s ‘disengagement’ from Gaza and his everyday life, Gaza was pushed in the oblivion of his consciousness. Since he began coming to the circle he found in it his chance to get closer to the conflict and know more about the reasons for the recent exacerbation. Gazan youngsters don’t know Israelis, and vice versa. In Migdalor Nahshi found his niche for activism. In historical perspective, past attempts of political frameworks have not succeeded. Israel erased Gaza from public awareness. Nahshi is doing something minor, and good – for himself as well. The forum is interesting. He believes that the grains of sand will unite as “terra firma” – stable ground. The anomality cannot last forever. He has renewed his contact with the Gazans he knew, a family who had worked on his kibbutz. Some time ago, he tells whoever did not know, a cooking gas container blew up. Said, one of the brothers he had known, dies of his wounds. They were glad to renew contact with Nahshi who even raised money in his kibbutz after the destruction of their building block plant following that accident, but now they are disconnected again. There is a mango fruit merchant with whom he speaks occasionally. He tells of the Harassment by Hamas. They have sought ways to meet. The man has dealings with Israel. They were looking for a way to meet through “The Road to Recovery” (Israeli volunteer actions to take Palestinian patients to hospitals from the checkpoints to hospitals inside Israel), so when some aunt of this fellow hade to undergo treatment in Israel Nahshi helped drive her and a chance to listen and speak. There are people behind the stories, and many years of erased awareness.
Bella came for her own sake. She can express her inner feelings. She doesn’t see them, but she feels them. Because of our group, there is hope. We are undergoing a bad period of time. There is nothing to expect from the leaders, they don’t count us. Here she is able to raise her voice for peace. We might despair, but the Gazans are far more desperate. She dreams of a better future and has came to the meeting for the coffee…
Mark feels frustrated about the circle but says it’s his own fault, not the circle’s. The circle was important for him. He found his own ability to change and raise his head. He recalls the European radical left’s own modes of action. People in the circle helped him dare ask questions that contest the mainstream’s idea of things. The next step, supposedly more active, is not yet here. He knows that as a Jewish citizen in Israel his own words and deeds touch upon non-Jewish citizens, and that injustice is carried out in his name. Environment interests him but there too it is theory and not practice that has the upper hand. Criticism has not helped, and his has no criticism of the others. He studies Arabic with Haneen who has left two children and a husband and moved to Portugal. He says Haneen is troubled by the upcoming planned annexation. She can be met on the “We Are Not Numbers” website. Mark speaks with her about the “Youth Committee”, about Alaa and Liora. She thinks that youngsters from both sides should be speaking about the occupation before they get into joint projects. Heneen is in a difficult mental state in the present situation, separated from her own family. Mark suggests that Migdalor participants bring up ideas in writing. Writing is significant. Perhaps publish an anthology of papers.
Michal has come because of Hayuta… She is not political. She is curious. Came to check it out… Mostly listening. Nomika has many activism items on her resume, in the framework of “Other Voice”. Today she was on a Palestine tour organized by the Ir Amim (Jerusalem) association that took place to show people the significance of annexation. Every few months she tours the occupied territories with a different organization. More landgrab, more confiscations. She spoke of a joint project that employs engineers from Gaza, the West Bank and Israel. There are many demonstrations protesting the annexation that are not at all covered in the media. The book, Alone in Berlin, is a constitutive book regarding am individual’s action resisting the ruling consensus. She suggests planning an event at the Erez Crossing. The PA’s committee on interacting with Israeli society has renewed its activity. They should be invited to the Migdalor circle. Finally, she spoke extensively about the American hospital project in Gaza.
And finally, an apology: last week I wrote that Nurit, Uzi’s sister, came for the first time. Not true! She has already been with us 4 times. All power to her…
Participants: Hayuta,k Shmulik, Malki, Dina, Nahshi, Mark, Oded, Michal, Bella, Nomika.
Wrote: Oded

encounter no. 118 – June 19, 2020

That’s right, we meet at our Migdalor (“lighthouse”) every Friday in order to preserve our awareness of Gaza. That Gazans would know that we’re not forgetting, and that we remember that people there are suffering and we should support them in any possible way, even if only morally.
But today was different somehow. Yesterday the destruction equipment of the Israel Land Administration demolished 3 structures at Al Zarnouk, an unrecognized Bedouin village situated about 12 kilometers east of Beer Sheva. Jaber comes from Al Zarnouk.
Usually when Jaber introduces himself in our circle, says he comes from an unrecognized village, but in spite of all the problems he faces as a Bedouin citizen of Israel whose rights are trampled constantly, he still knows that his life is considered rather good compared to that of the Gazans. But today, after the home demolitions in his own community, his feelings of frustration and rage are practically uncontrollable. Jaber is on the verge of tears. He speaks of his attempts to apply to the authorities to suspend demolitions, about the mental damage to families and residents, about the attempts to injure the Negev Arab society. Desperately he emphasizes the mean cynicism in the appointment of Yair Ma’ayan – the man who founded and is CEO of Regavim, an organization aimed at harassing any attempt by a non-Jew to settle in the country – to the office of CEO of “The Authority for Development and Settlement of Bedouins in the Negev”… Ironically, this is the authority that is supposed to be the one which Bedouins turn to when someone is to solve their problems. Jaber feels guilty for not having been able to prevent the destruction.
Coincidentally or not, today’s topic of discussion is “home”… After Jaber speaks, everyone remains silent.
Then Rami says he too feels guilty that such things take place while we relax at home. Home and land are certainly important, but it’s important for us to be there for each other. My home is your home, as the saying goes, as Rami says to Jaber.
Shmulik tells us that in the 2011 social protest demonstrations he joined one of the public discussions and said there that state funds go to settler-colonies instead of where they are most needed. He was kicked out of the discussion and accused of being a communist…
Ghadir says that Arabs have to struggle over every centimeter of living space, there are home demolitions by the state taking place every single day.
Miri comes from the religious Zionist sector. The community she was born in was founded on the ruins of Palestinian village Sawafir. She studied at Bar Ilan University (Israel’s religious institution of higher learning) and lived in the same room with a friend from Baq’a Al Gharbiya. She was often asked if she wasn’t afraid her Arab friend would kill her… She worked for years with Israeli army disabled veterans. At present, retired, she coordinates transporting Palestinian patients to hospitals in Israel, in the “Way to Recovery” association. The disengagement announced by the Palestinian Authority (caused by threats of annexation by Israel) has become a real problem, the state of ill patients in Gaza is catastrophic. Children who usually enter Israel every fortnight for treatment, and cannot return home but stay quarantined in a Gaza hotel until their next treatment… Paradoxically, the nurses at the hospital say that these children look healthier during their hotel stay than when they’re at home…
Jamal, now living in Tel Sheva, had his home demolished in 1996 right in front of his two little daughters who are now schoolteachers. He has been evicted and displaced from his home three times. In 1948 his family was divided between Gaza and Israel, was united in 1967 (he studied in Gaza), and torn apart again when Arafat came under the Oslo Accords and chased away from Gaza all Palestinians holding an Israeli ID. His father, grandfather and other family members are buried there. Jamal says that Gaza is “the world’s guinea pig”. Relating to what Jaber told us, he speaks of the initiative of inhabitants of unrecognized villages to create a regional council for 26 communities, of which only 11 are officially recognized, and even that without most of the usual rights. Bedouins constitute 36% of the Negev population, and inhabit 2.3% of its area…
Dina says the problems should be treated fundamentally. She identifies with Jaber. She uses words like “injustice”, “lost opportunities” and “indirect communication”, and thinks the right bodies need be approached…
Nahshi is here to remind himself that right here, close by in Gaza, there are people who need our help and it’s good for them to realize we’re here every week. Nahshi thinks that here in Israel we are able to do more to oppose organizations like Regavim and says he will be at the demonstration on Monday!
Shelly recalls the first time in her life when she felt a sense of injustice, in the kibbutz children’s house where she grew up… She is well-versed in the Negev Bedouins’ history and adds important details. She speaks of a friend in Hebron whose home was demolished, and in desperation pushed his baby boy into the arms of the officer who “secured” the demolition operation, and told him: “Raise him yourself…” He was tried for assaulting an officer by means of a baby, and was sentenced to a long time in jail but released after 10 months for his failing health. Shelly says that another friend of hers told her we must continue doing what we can even if it does not seem to be solving anything, for perhaps the solution is right around the corner…
I like the way Uzi introduces himself: “I was born a year before the Nakba of 1948 and came to Gvulot a year before the Occupation of 1967…” Uzi is a Middle-East scholar. He says he has a lot to say but we’re close to our finishing time and makes do with saying that “Gaza is deep sorrow and a terrible miss”.
Nurit is Uzi’s sister and is with us for the first time.
Malki choose to say that the Migdal-Or (that’s how she wishes to call it – in Hebrew, literally: Tower of light) is an anchor for her. Everyone wishes to fell “at home”.
Ghadir also says that the Migdalor is home, and Jaber concludes our meeting saying we mustn’t lose hope, he feels at home here.
So do I, because it’s sort of obvious, isn’t it?
After everyone gets up Ghadir says to me quietly – we didn’t mention our arrested friends…
Participants: Jaber, Shelly, Shmulik, Rami, Ghadir, Oded, Malki8, Jamal, Uzi, Dina, Nahshi, Nurit, Miri
Wrote: Oded

encounter no. 117 – June 12, 2020

Greetings,
In the shade of the pine tree on top of the hill, in the open air – we met: Roni, Rami, Shmulik Nomika and Hayuta.
After our opening words about who, what and when, Roni brought Rami’s question; to what extent do the recent encounters touch upon Gaza and focus on it.
Shmulik thought that everything is political, and the fact that these encounters dealt with subjects decided on ahead of time such as refugee-dom or land created interesting meetings that refreshed people’s perspectives.
We decided that on Sunday the ‘syndicate’ would meet and decide its take on the matter.
This week’s recommendation is to read David Grossman’s essay, “We are all a sticky human brocade” and listening to Ahinoam Nini’s song based on this essay, called “Signs of Innocence”. Let it be…
Wrote: Hayuta

Encounter 116 – June 5, 2020

In our ‘mingling’ time at the start, someone asked about our arrested friends… This time, unlike the past weeks, someone else answered that they have ben seen, but their release is not yet on the horizon.
The feeling of frustration in their answer made Rami suggest that today’s topic of conversation would be “frustration”. Someone else reminded us of our resolution at the end of our last session, to continue with the topic of “land”.
The two topics very soon bonded… Since we had guests from the north of the country today, we held a real acquaintance circle. Eli, from the north, told about his activity with the “Committee for Interaction with Israeli Society” founded by the Palestinian Authority. Eli handles the encounters of young Israelis with Palestinians from the West Bank, especially Israelis of the pre-military service seminars who are met and influenced especially by people of the right-wing and political center. According to him, reinforced by what Shoshi said, also from the north of the country, these encounters have given the Israelis a perspective they had never before met among Palestinians.
“Land”
I began a circle and spoke about my impressions of Meron Benbenisti’s descriptions in his book The White Prickly Pear [“sabra” in Hebrew], regarding the systemic and politically-guided erasure of the Palestinian landscape that had been filled with fruit tree groves, prickly-pear hedges and rural stone masonry and erased by the State of Israel after the 1948 war.
Micha cited poet Shaul Tchernichowsky’s “see, land, how wasteful we have been”…
Jaber complained about the denied possibility of getting to know the people living across the fence, a denial that leads to mutual demonization.
Nahshi emphasized the tremendous mass that land has. It’s a mass that reduces any obstacle trying to bring about separation.
Malki said that the topic of land directly associated with Mercedes Sosa’s “Cuando Tenga la Tierra” and had us hear it.
Rami spoke about how the world “has forgotten Gaza”, and said that just like air and water, land-earth exists on its own. The use of ideas such as “holding on to the land” or “sanctifying the land” does not define his own regard of the land. He also told us that the woods we sit in every week were planted artificially by the State of Israel over a vast area that had been farmed by Palestinians with grain fields. He calls this grove of pines, eucalypti and other trees “political trees”. Landscape-erasure erases one’s awareness, he adds in conclusion.
Micha wishes to say that this might not be relevant right now, but just at this moment in time many men and women rabbis in Jerusalem are fasting right now to commemorate George Floyd murdered by a Minneapolis policeman and Iyad Al Halaq murdered in Jerusalem by an Israeli policeman.
Roni touches us with a poem she has written commemorating Razan Al Nazar, shot to death by an Israeli sniper while caring – as a professional nurse – for the wounded during the protest demonstrations along the Gazan fence two years ago.
Bella said that land is supposed to be tied to “permanence” and “rootedness” but this is an illusion and she thinks just like Rami about the issue.
Shmulik, however, finds them wrong, thinking that land is definitely validated by humans.
Uzi related to a poem by Mahmoud Darwish, “On this Earth”, which Nomika had brought to the circle last week. Uzi examined the translation Nomika brought against other translations and found that a part of the poem emphasized by Nomika gets a different meaning in another translation. He brought this part in the original Arabic. Ghadir and Jaber approved that the translation he brought was the right one… Ghadir practically choked while telling about her forced separation from family members who cannot meet her because of the siege on Gaza. She was angered by the sign she saw near the entrance gate of Kibbutz Sa’ad calling for returning the sons home, meaning the Jewish, ignoring the two Bedouins, citizens of this state, also held hostage by the Hamas.
Just as we were finishing up, Uri and Sarit from Arad arrived. Seeing our circle they were sure they had come upon a birthday celebration. When they came closer they realized – just like all Israelis – that they know one of us and she knows them. Although we had crossed our 4 p.m. limit, they were a good excuse for another coffee round (Nahshi, who else…?) and the tasty tidbits covered against the local flies.
Finally, for all those afraid of the heat, it’s hard to share with you this pleasant place by photo or video, but it is really truly pleasant there!
Participants: Jaber, Rami, Roni, Malki, Uzi, Ghadir, Shmulik, Bella, Oded, Micha, Shoshi, Eli, Uri, Sarit
Witing: Oded

Encounter no. 115 -May 29, 2020

Today – no Zoom. On the one hand it “releases” the circle for there is no need to speak in a way that would make the audio-visual technology feasible. On the other hand, through Zoom other participants are included in the circle to partners that would not likely participate normally. The question, then, is how to enlarge our circle even if for various reasons there are no random travelers passing by, and people are still confused about going out and getting together with others. To be considered… I think that half an hour of Zoom, in spite of the complications, is quite valuable.
Another question raised every time for weeks now, is “What do we know?” about our participants who have been suffering because of their courage and can no longer voice their brave messages. We miss them, as well as information about their fate.
Moshe, born in Argentina, tells us about a group he counseled there who were arrested by the generals’ junta in the country in the mid-1970s. He already lived in Israel at the time and, with several of his friends, made various attempts to free the group, in spite of messages “suggesting” non-interference. This is indeed a difficult situation in which one hardly knows whether interference and outside pressure would be effective, if action should be covert so as not to “provoke”.
The subject for our circle today was suggested by Rami – “land”. Since not enough time was left for such a broad issue, we proposed to continue next time, June 5.
From the little that was said it appears that “land” represents many contexts – farming, political, emotional, philosophical, historical etc. It might express a spectrum of feelings by various people depending on the context in which they encounter reality, and naturally, as we all know and experience, create bloody confrontations and conflict. So we shall continue discussing it in our next meeting. Prepare your arguments!
That’s it, the time is past 4 p.m., the Muslims have terminated their Ramadan fast followed by three days of the Id al Fitr holiday, and we have a Shavuot (Jewish holiday) ceremony two hours from now… Holiday greetings for all the inhabitants of this earth.
Participants today: Nahshi, Roni, Shmulik, Ghadir, Rami, Oded, Jaber, Hanan, Moshe, Shelly, Nomika, Eric, Mary, Sarale
Written by Oded

Lighthouse meeting 114 – 22.5.2020

After a week of sizzling temperatures, we enjoyed a certain coolness on Friday. The shade under the pine trees was pleasant and welcomed those who chose to come as guests, meet and share coffee.
The first subject at hand was the idea of “refugee-dom”:
Rafi, participating through Zoom, spoke about his mother who had to emigrate from Austria to Palestine in the 1930s, against her will. He thinks that the state of the inhabitants of unrecognized villages in the Negev fit this definition, because even if they live where they were born, still the regime changes stole their rights and they became refugees in their own homes.
Mary, also through Zoom, sent the “UN Convention Regarding the Status of Refugees”, as signed in a special UN assembly in Geneva, June 28, 1951, and enforced since April 22, 1954.
Jaber identified himself as the only refugee sitting in our circle, as he is a Bedouin living in an unrecognized village. Roni argued that this somewhat stands out of the definition as “refugee”. One should not mix injustices – each evil has its own definition…
Roni gave her husband Ovadia as an example of a refugee – he was expelled out of Egypt as a youth because of the persecution of Jews in Arab countries following the founding of the State of Israel). He however did not bewail his fate and reconstructed his life.
Shmulik spoke about a Syrian soldier who beat up his commander and escaped, crossing the border into Israel. After spending time in an Israeli jail, it was decided to send him to a kibbutz under certain security limitations, until he would find a country to which he could emigrate. Thus he arrived at Kibbutz Nir Yitzchak (refugee?…).
Hayuta said that Roni’s words honed for her the idea of “choice” as a possibility of distinguishing between a person forced to leave their home and one who chooses to leave even if life is made worse with this choice.
Nomika spoke about her mother who was also brought to Israel against her choice, but the worse context her mother experienced regarding refugee-dom was when she served in the 1948 war as a propaganda officer and had to accompany foreign journalists in the north of the country. On their way, she received the message: “Don’t come to the Galilee, we’re cleansing the area”. This was the great expulsion of Palestinians into Lebanon and Syria.
Jaber said that acknowledge by those responsible for the injustice they caused comprises most of the solution, but a historical event that he mentioned excitedly led to an interesting discussion in the Whatsapp group. Jaber mentioned “bombs that were thrown into synagogues in order to make Jews escape to Israel”… Mary asked for clarifications, and Smadaar and Nahshi sent material about the Zionist underground in Iraq.
The second topic (brought up by Nomika), was the memory of each and every participant about the turning point in their consciousness – some event that brought about change in the way they saw reality in Israel.
Nomika began, telling about her childhood in a Hashomer Ha-Tza’ir kibbutz near a ‘developing’ town (usually populated by new immigrants from Arab countries), and her friendship with girls her age from that town who were callously chased away from the kibbutz by the kibbutzniks when they came to visit her, thus putting an end to that friendship.
Shmulik spoke about his connection with three Arab youths his age who worked in Kibbutz Ga’ash before he joined the army in the early 1960s. From them he first heard about the fate of Palestinians in the country.
Nahshai told us that his high school studies had been most selective, and that with his teachers it was decided that he would spend his time in the library rather than in class. There he was exposed to the weekly “Ha-Olam Ha-Ze” which, beside bare-breasted young women in its back cover, wrote about the injustices taking place in the country, among them occupation and military government. When Nahshi met friends from kibbutz Kerem Shalom who were fighting the injustices of Israeli occupation in Gaza, he realized the reality of the things he had read about.
Jaber told us he had wanted to become a tour guide, and someone told him to buy textbooks in Hebron, for they are cheaper there… His reading opened up for him alternative facts (to put it mildly) rather than what he had previously learnt in the Israeli school system (he had thorough Bible studies, and not a word about Palestinians…).
I spoke about the first Lebanon War, 1982, when I was exposed to false reports from the ground, and consequently began to doubt first the media and then all of the indoctrination I had absorbed in the life systems that surround us in this country.
Gili too (a first-timer) recalls entering that war as an ardent Israeli patriot, but when he was ordered to shoot to kill, he was not able to do so, and fired at the ground. A turning point.
Miri (also a first-timer) grew up in a religious-Zionist settlement, and when studying at Bar Ilan University, met a fellow student who was an Arab woman. They became friends and shared a room at the students’ dorms. Their friendship was tested both in December 1975 after a terrorist attack at Ramat Magshimim, and on Land Day in late March 1978 while they were still at university.
Roni’s turning point was when she spent time with her family on an agricultural mission in Egypt, and her daughter befriended a classmate of Palestinian origin. At first the girl’s mother boycotted the girls’ friendship, but by the end of their time there Roni and the Palestinian mother had become good friends, which naturally affected Roni’s views.
This time we finished at 4:30 p.m. That’s what happens when you enjoy what you’re doing…
Participants on the ground and by Zoom: Nomika, Shmulik, Jaber, Hayuta, Roni, Nahshi, Oded, Miri, Gil, Hagar, Mary, Rafi, Shmulike
Reported by Oded