About 10 days ago cooking gas tanks exploded at a bakery in Nuseirat refugee camp, in the central Gaza Strip. The bakery shares a wall with a building block factory belonging to a family some of whose sons used to work at Kibbutz Nir Yitzchak in the past. Nine people were killed on the spot and several dozens wounded and burned to several degrees of severity. By today the number of deaths has risen to 17. The bakery and the factory are totally ruined.
In our circle we spoke with Ibrahim whose brother Saoud is hospitalized in Gaza, suffering burns over 50% of his body. Ibrahim was very moved to speak with our Shmulik. They used to work together in the cowshed and longingly reminisced about their shared breakfasts on the dung heap… He excitedly asked about many people he remembered from that time in the kibbutz and shared memories with Nahshi, who had contacted the family after the disaster. They are trying to recover and accompany Saoud and the other wounded to full recovery and rehabilitation. The conversation was moving and in spite of the tragedy, filled with warmth and pure, simple human feelings of brotherhood.
We were four from Nir Yitzchak today – Shmulik, Nahshi, Moshe Rosen and myself. We had no high expectations. The weather was stormy. We settled down and informed people we were here…
After a short while Mary arrived, with her umbrella and short sleeves… We made small talk and the rain surprised us with its direction.
We retreated to the closed room while three young ladies crossed our path. We turned on our aging charms and offered coffee… Apparently hot coffee on a cold rainy day and the company of four aging men and a retired Ministry of Health woman employee did the trick:
All three girls – Danielle, Daniel and Achinoam – joined the circle. Two of them live nearby and the third in the center of the country.
The circle was joined by Mustafa, father of Wafat, the shepherdess who sat with us for a while last week, armed with hot tea while her sister stayed with the grazing sheep.
Our talk with the girls was fascinating, especially – I think – because of the gaps and differences in our awareness of the Gaza Strip and in relation to the greater space that surrounds our presence in this land. It was also interesting to listen to their talk, the words in which each generation chooses to express its views and opinions. In conclusion, nine people sat in the circle, plus a friend from Gaza on the phone – the whole was greater than the sum of its parts, and the Coronavirus pandemic was (almost) not mentioned for three hours!
Four o’clock. We disperse in pouring rain.
Oded
Monthly Archives: May 2020
Lighthouse 103 – March 6, 2020
Yes, today too our determined/ crazy/ visionary/ delusional circle (erase whichever you choose or add whatever you like) took place. So who was there? Bearded Shmulik, bespectacled Oded, Roni who brought her marvelous pastries, and Hayuta, writing this report.
Coffee boiled, herb tea was made ready, and in between the rain clouds dad Shmuli with his skullcap appeared with two of his children: no. 9 – Ra’ya, and no. 10 – Yehuda. They are our guests for the second time now. The family lives in the settler colony of Rosh Tzurim in the Etzyon bloc.
The children played, bickered and wondered about our presence. Ra’ya said – “we offered them things and they only fire rockets at us”. Yehuda was inquisitive about the place and its past. Ra’ya wanted to know “what do you think of the evacuation of the settler colonies in the Gaza Strip?”
Suddenly sheep appeared and a beautiful shepherdess. She lives in Dimona. Enjoyed refreshments and drank tea.
At the end she received all the leftovers from Shmulike and Oded.
In short, the father and his children entertained us…
Hayuta
Lighthouse 102 – February 28, 2020
For me Gaza means complexity, people, out of bounds, a flourishing garden, childhood memories, friends, something we’re responsible for.
And we are for Gaza: Roni, Rami, Mary, Radir, Jaber, his wife Hitham and their son Walid, Nahshi, Yigal, Malki with her sister, aunt, nieces and friends.
Present were also Rami from Gaza by phone, and a bus with 47 members of the Ma’a lot Tiv’on Reform Judaism.
The travelers who happened by and gave us new insights this time were a couple from Shoham (he is the CEO of the Umm Al Fahm municipality) and a couple from Yahoud. Others who came by and got curious simply had no more room…
The group from Tiv’on sang a peace song written by Mickey Dinstein for Kibbutz Nirim in 1958, touching even Rami and his pals in Gaza across the line.
We said we mustn’t accept the separation and hostility that have been imposed on us and on Gaza, and that everyone benefits form cooperation and acquaintance. That the next generation growing up in Gaza will bring peace, and that we hope for a miracle in the elections, and that there is always a partner for talking.
The circle went on way over 4 p.m. and beyond the Gaza region.
Nahshi
Lighthouse 101 – February 21, 2020
Present were Rami, Roni, Nomika, Arik, Rinat, Malki, Uzi, Hanan, Limor and Nahshi.
Many travelers came close and many of them even sat down with us in our circle: a couple from Be’er Ya’acov, a young man born in Kibbutz Re’im who came with a Greek friend, a couple from Be’erotayim on the Green Line, a Bedouin shepherd grazing his flock nearby, four vicycle riders from Tel Aviv and Rishon Le-Tziyon, Dina from Kibbutz Gvulot, friends of Malki from Mevaseret Tziyon, other friends of Malki’s from Arugot whose names are unforgettable (Shlomo and Shlomit…), Vivian and Orit from Kibbutz Be’eri, Rachel from Harish who defined herself as a peace-loving religious Jew and said she had taken part in a story translation project from Gaza – “We Across the Fence”, and there were also Gidi and his wife from Nirim who came back from the 96th “Hadar Vigil” (demanding the return of Hadar Goldin, Oron Shaul, Ebre Mengisto and Hisham A-Sayed).
We spoke about the transparency of the Gazans whom no one actually sees, about the conflict, about the tension that has caused us to lose our ability to empathize with our neighbors, about the leaders who “manage” the conflict instead of solving it; about the fact that acquaintance is a condition for understanding and the ability to reach agreements. The problem is that on both sides people know ‘the other’ less and less, and have almost given up trying; about the fact that one can no longer celebrate birthdays with balloons in our area.
And after all of that, it is in fact people, lots of people in Israel and in Gaza who can improve their lives if we only manage to leave violence behind.
… This time we did not manage to speak with our Gazan friends on the phone, but we save their place in our hearts and in our circle.
Nahschi
Lighthouse 100 – February 14, 2020
Lighthouse 100th anniversary festivity hosted close to 100 men, women and children today. The hosts were Oded, Hayuta, Roni, Jaber, Mark of Kibbutz Urim, and Mark of Kfar Aza, Shmulik, Shelly, Nahshi, Limor, Or and the two filmmakers (this is their last time as such, next they will attend as “normal” participants), Mary, Radir, Rami from Gaza by phone, and thousands of beautiful anemones decorating the nearby valleys, trails and tracks.
Two groups of travelers arrived and sat down, several others came by and inquired about the strange bunch sitting inside. The first group to be seated were people from the north of the country. The second group was mixed with people who had traveled together in Japan and came from various parts of the country. The two groups sat with us, listened, heard us and responded. The feeling was that they were with us in heart and mind. One of the visitors, a neighbor from Kibbutz Tze’elim, was very moved and hugged Radir tightly.
The coffee and anemones brought to us two lovely families with their children: one from Faran in the Arava desert, father Rotem, mother Rotem, and their children Naomi, Lia and Oded who sat and listened, and empowered us. The other family was from Kibbutz Hanita – mother Shani, father Sagi, and their children Joel and Ariel. The father told us about the carpentry shop he shares with his close friend from a neighboring Arab village. He insisted that human closeness taught him to what extent their similarity is so much more significant than their differences.
Two other friends – Khaled and Naif, impressive in their fluent Hebrew – came from the Arab village of Abu Talul, near Kibbutznik Jaber. They expressed their appreciation for our circle.
Other guests were Nomika and Shmulik, and finally Dganit, Ilan, and Jill from Eilat/Be’eri.
Rami told us how irritated he gets with leaders busy with slogans, who refrain from improving the lives of people on the ground. To Limor’s question, he said he would go out and sign up 100 Gazans who declare they wish to live in neighborly peace and refrain from any violent acts. After he is through signing people up in Gaza, he is more than willing to cross the fences and sign up a similar number of Israelis with the same intentions.
Summing up, the circle, its existence and awareness of Gaza have been disseminated far and wide.
Hayuta
Lighthouse 99 – February 7, 2020
A little while after our arrival, another car came to the parking area and man with a cowboy hat disembarked. He turned and walked away from the British sulfur plant where we were assembling as we are wont, for our 99th weekly meeting.
“Ah-huh” I said to Nahshi and Shmulik who came with me, and to Mark who had also arrived – “here’s someone who really doesn’t want us to invite him”.
We continued arranging our seats and two minutes later the cowboy hat entered. Underneath the hat was Jeff Parness. Jeff, a veteran ‘Migdalorist’ who lives in New York said to his wife on Sunday that “there’s a flight in three hours”. Yesterday he was already lying amidst the (Israeli) wild anemones and photographing himself…
He was followed, one after another, by Micha, Roni, Gadir, Mohammad (from Bu’eine village in the Galilee, a teacher in Nazareth), Ye’ela, Limor, Raz (from Haifa) and his friend Liza (from Germany) – two travelers who have been charmed by the wonders of our circle, and like them – Shai and Shaked, still in uniform, travelling together on their weekend leave.
Niva and Noa also arrived, and for our last hour – Mirale, her daughter Neta and graddaughter Keren.
Last to arrive was Rami who had returned from a meeting at Neve Shalom and entered with a young couple he picked up on the way. They stayed only for a short while and we didn’t manage to ask them their names…
As we do every week, we also hosted Rami and Manar who were only present with their voices on the telephone. While we listened to them Shmulik went out to meet a group of travelers who were curious but preferred to keep their distance. Shmulik, of course, spoke to them about the charms of the circle and its importance for regional reconciliation.
The sharp-sighted among you will note that I haven’t yet mentioned Uri’s presence. Well, this Uri who – in his opinion – holds views opposed to “ours”, came in order to wipe out graffiti drawn a few months ago on the plant wall. Uri, who joins the circle occasionally, felt obliged to wipe out the graffiti because he knows the person who wrote it. With roller and white paint, the graffiti was soon all gone. Then Uri joined the circle.
Naturally with so many participants an acquaintance circle was necessary and we went ahead with it.
Surprisingly the weather was nice and unlike the predictions clear and not particularly cold. The designed coffee cups were filled one by one and served by Nahshi to all interested…
Notably absent this time were the film students from Sapir College who have been filming us for 10 weeks running, and did not show up today… Well, we’re not offended, but we miss them…
Oded
Topics that came up:
• Faith and hope – what do they mean for our anticipation of sanity returning to the region;
• Micha read out a poem by Robert Frost about neighborliness and fences/walls;
• Rami said he does not wish to speak about Trump, Bibi and manipulations for staying in office. He is waiting for the day when Gadir will be Israel’s Prime Minister and Jeff President of the US;
Lighthouse 98 – January 31, 2020
At some point, after we spoke with Rami from Gaza, I looked around the circle:
There were Roni, Shmulik and Hanan, Nahshi and Limor, Mirale, Neta, Mary and Naomi, Julia, Malki, Uzi and Bela, Hayuta, Jaber, Shmulik as well as Rami from Gaza. A community.
After nearly two years and close to one-hundred encounters every Friday, rain or shine, we have become a community. All those who were there today keep the “routine” of the circle. Every week, or once every two or three or four weeks. Coming, supporting, listening and sounding.
In the past ten weeks, the filmmaking students of Sapir College have also become a part of the community. Today we had with us Shani, Naor and Or.
We arrived earlier than usual. We wished to add a creativity corner to the usual circle. A collaboration with “Another Voice”. The idea was to suggest to travelers who come to see nature’s wonders and arrive at the sulfur plant to draw on paper sheets or on stars (“Hope Stars”, a project by Jeff of New York where people draw or write a message of hope to communities suffering from a natural disaster or war or any other disaster, and Jeff and his people pass it to them). We wanted to hand up the drawings or stars on a wall inside the plant.
The weather didn’t really cooperate and a cold wind was blowing. Few travelers arrived, and even less children. Those who arrived didn’t stay for long and proceeded on their way. Anyway, they had a cuppa or at least stayed long enough to politely refuse… The creativity corner remained solitary…
Still, Reut and Shai from Jerusalem sat with us and for them we held a proper circle. They too were a bit stressed for time, wishing to return the bikes they had rented. But from the little we heard we understood that especially Shai bears “scars” from the unsolved confrontation in the region (his grandfather was murdered in the “bloodshed bus”, a tourist busload of Israeli tourists attacked in Egypt, commemorated by the memorial sculpture at Yad Mordechai Junction). What about Gaza? Reut and Shai oppose any harm done to innocents, not only in Gaza – anywhere.
Later we spoke with Rami, helped by Jaber as translator. Towards the end of the circle we were joined by Hitam and Walid, wife and son of Jaber who had been hiking around the area while Jaber sat with us. Around 3 p.m. the cold won and our “community” began to disperse. At 3:30 p.m. we folded knowing that if we arrived early, it was no tragedy to leave earlier as well…
Oded
Issues raised:
• No one believes in Trump’s peace initiative deal, but it has its advantages such as uniting factions among the Palestinians;
• Leaders on both sides would lay the responsibility at Trump’s door, something that has not happened for years now;
• Organizing for “Darom Adom” (Red South) – we shall try to hold vigils and open our circle on Saturdays as well during the month of February;
• Rami said that if they are issued an entry permit – he and ten of the youngsters with him – they would travel throughout Israel and explain to anyone willing to listen that Gazans too want to live in peace;
Lighthouse 97 – January 24, 2020
One could way “it was raining” or “it was cold”, or “nobody’d show up”. One could say “fanatics!”, or “if you get sick, take of yourself on your own” (my woman), and other great reasons why not to hold the “circle” today.
If we say all of it, it would all be true. For this mission, we needed a practical idiot.
There were four practical idiots: Rami, Roni, Shmulik and myself (average age – 70…)
Actually we were nine: the four of us were joined by Naor, Shani, Or and his girlfriend Naomi, and another Or without his girlfriend (average age – 25…).
First we tried to block out cold, rainy nature by tying a tarpaulin up at the entrance to our structure, but finally decided to sit inside the relatively closed room on the west side of the structure.
Rami, prepared in advance, lit a small campfire and we all crowded around it.
The young focused on their assignment: a documentary film project for their second-year film studies at Sapir College. Shani filmed, Or recorded, and the other Or signaled filming directions and wiped the tears caused by the campfire’s smoke. Naor was our reserves force and Naomi studies law in Jerusalem. The circle began with jokes and mutual teasing between myself and Rami, and we when we got bored we proceeded to the acquaintance circle, especially in honor of Naomi for whom this was a first time.
Rami was also responsible for coffee and tea. He repeated the religious blessing over the refreshment which he had learned at home, tore apart the hala that Shmulik brought, baked by Tomer the baker of Nir Yitzchak.
We of the ‘average age – 70’ then had a long discussion about activity during the “Red South” Festival. At some point Rami asked the youngsters for their opinion on the matter. Apparently we’re not the only wise ones… They spoke well, had their own output and gave our ideas their feedback.
Just before dispersing Rami read us things he wrote in the morning before heading out to the Lighthouse. He wrote his answer to the message he received from the founders of “The New Guard”, about helping their activity/. True, his answer was not related to Gaza which is the ground of our activity, but perhaps indirectly – through his criticism of the exclusivist Judeo-Israeli attitude they reflect which might clarify the Israeli view of Gaza.
His writing was thought-provoking and well formulated (I suggested he send it to Haaretz newspaper, and he responded with a giggled shrug…). They should be read. I believe his words echo our world view.
Then we dispersed, entered our heated cars and drove to our heated homes. We left Gaza out there…
Oded
Lighthouse 96 – January 17, 2020
So finally, it was almost 4 p.m., and Radir read out in Arabic a text written originally in Dutch by a Jewish woman murdered in the Holocaust. She read and wept, wept and fell silent. And for a while everyone fell silent with her. We were one circle united in silence. Radir read from a card, the text by Eti Hilsum, a Jewish Dutch woman murdered in 1943 by the Nazis, in the Holocaust. She was 29 years old when she was murdered. The cards with Hilsum’s quotes, translated from Dutch into Arabic, Hebrew and English were brought by Emma Sham-Ba. She is an Israeli dividing her time between Israel and Portugal, where she is active in the Tamera community for a world without wars and for preserving its living qualities. Emma came with Patrick of Holland who photographed and documented her and us.
When we read the cards that Emma handed out to us with quotes and insights by Eti Hilsum, we were already 25 participants in the circle on a rainy day.
We had begun at 1 p.m. – the regulars – Roni, Shmulik, Nahshi and Oded. Mark arrived to be with us as well, though he has lately showed up less at the Migdalor because he has become more active in favor of a sustainable planet.
Limor – who arrived with Yefet and Nina, the furry, barking couple – helped us put up the chair circle. Later, when Emma and Patrick arrived, we opened the introduction circle as always.
In the meantime we chatted, while Or (2nd year film student at Sapir College) continued to gather us into his camera for the seventh week in a row, and Nahshi handed out coffee cups in new ceramics created especially for us by Vered Altman, a ceramist from Nir Yitzchak (and entirely her own initiative!)
Then came Radir and Jaber, who has begun to bring a coffe thermos and a tea thermos from home. Okay, we’re taking it in stride…
And here – walking towards the circle – are Gabriella, her boyfriend Eitan, and her sister Safriella. After hearing a short explanation about our circular presence, they “contribute” their own Gaza awareness, as is expected of every participant.
Maor, Mir and Yorai come down and join the circle. They too add their opinions about Gaza.
Here’s Marie, who likes to come because complexities arouse her interest. She has been coming every week for about two months, and says that Gaza is interesting in its complexity.
About 3:30 p.m. Rami arrives. He finished his studies around Tel Aviv and drove straight to the Lighthouse. At the end of the encounter he would speak. Now he is kissing Emma whom he knows from elsewhere, and listens with us all – including Sholti and Hannale from the north, and Rika from Tel Aviv, who came from a funeral at Lehavim straight to the Lighthouse. Power to you!
So we all listen to our friend Rami in Gaza who speaks with us through Roni’s cell phone, and his words are carried to us all through the loudspeaker.
At the entrance another young couple stands, somewhat self-conscious, seeing and hearing the goings-on. I approach them to explain. Nahshi suggests something (guess what) and they sit down. Thus Shira of Beer Sheva and her partner Tomer join the circle. The talk with Gazan Rami comes to an end.
Rami (of Beeri) tells a bit about the history of the Lighthouse idea and about new insights acquired in his studies. Emma hands out cards with the Hilsum quotes, and finally, almost at 4 p.m., Radir read out the text in Arabic, written originally in Dutch by a Jewish woman killed in the Holocaust.
Oded
Lighthouse 95 January 10, 2020
Participants: Rami, Roni, Jaber with his wife Khiam and son Walid, Ye’ela, Or, our two indefatigable photographers, and another four travelers in a jeep who enjoyed our explanations about the region and the sulfur mines.
Except for Gaza and the beautiful scenery around that can be seen in the photos, we sent our condolences and support to our friend Oded whose mother passed away, and her funeral was held while we were meeting.
Nahshi