It was day that seemed to say explicitly, listen kid, don’t try a day like me… Take a good book, a thick blanket, and some Mozart and don’t expose any part of your body to me. But what can we do… We have Gaza on the brain… We go to our Lighthouse encounter.
Shmulik is traveling in Acco, Nahshi is spending time in Tel Aviv, and Rami notifies us that he is a bit ill but will show up… My sister Racheli – here from Toronto to visit our aging mother – joins me.
Our way down to Be’eri is only cloudy. But from there on to our Lighthouse – it’s pouring! At the parking place we see one car from which Shani and Or, the film crew from Sapir, run out, loaded with equipment. They stop and take down their equipment. Shani says she feared that the weather would keep us from showing up. Fat chance… The area where we usually sit is all awash. We deliberate. Rami gets there, decides, and we sit and hope for the best.
There’s coffee, some pastry, and Marie from Beit Elazari arrives. Fourth time already! So we might end up with a fourth regular.
Shani and Or are already in action mode, filming. It’s raining and very very cold… Two youngsters peek at us from above. They are invited to join, sit down, have coffee, and we make our acquaintance rounds. Ayman and Sager from Kseife are travelers. Sager knows the area well. He worked at the landing strip. His family is from Saudi Arabia. His grandfather’s grandfather was looking for good pasture for his flocks and came to the Lakia area. They had never been to Gaza but very much want to visit (if you insist that we say something about Gaza…).
Marie, a retired employee of the Ministry of Health, has time and does what she pleases with it… She is attracted to complicated themes. Gaza is certainly one of them…
Racheli speaks of the effect our father has had on her views, and Rami asks for more information about the elderly man who answers to the title of “our father”.
As we tell his history, the Muezzin tears the pastoral silence. We have been coming here for 21 months every week, and have never experienced such a forceful voice.
The rain stops and the sun shines. We emerge, stand facing Gaza, and listen to the Muezzin. Marie says they are marking 11 years since the outbreak of what Israelis patriotically named “Operation Cast Lead”… That’s right – it all began on December 27, 2008. We Googled it…
A couple arrives from the parking area. We return to the circle. The couple are friends of Malki and Uzi who also show up some minutes later. Hagi and Iris. Hagi manages choirs and various musical projects (including Arab-Jewish joint events), and for him Gaza means memories of market and beach. Iris had been active in movement and dance for many years. Uzi says he was born a year before the Nakba (1948) and came to Kibbutz Gvulot a year before the 1967 occupation. The situation vis-à-vis Gaza causes him to feel loss and a deep sadness for what could be and is not happening. He claims both sides are to blame… Malki feels it is good for her to take part in the Lighthouse circles and wants to believe that things can change.
Rami repeats his explanations about the history of the structure and of the local agriculture that supplied rye to England’s beer breweries. The participants enjoy the amazing tea brought by Radir from the project at Wadi Atir. The halla and yeast-chocolate cake we brought from the Nir Yitzchak bakery are also very successful…
At 4 p.m., when we are almost through, Rami’s brother arrives with many nieces and nephews. They eat pastries and listen to Uncle Rami tell again about the sulfur plant building, this time standing up while I am already folding our chairs.
It was indeed a difficult day weather-wise, but as a take off on Gorodish (Israeli armor corps general) we could say we looked at the stormy weather in the eye and it lowered its gaze… (Gorodish said these words about… death).
Next week as usual. What, won‘t you be there?
Oded
Lighthouse 92, December 20, 2019
The circle today was surprising, interesting, videotaped and recorded. No doubt we’re nearing a well-attended and carpeted Oscars ceremony…
Two events of late were an active part of the circle this time: a film by Osa called “Other Voices” projected the evening before at Kibbutz Kisufim, and a well-attended conference of “Ro’im Ofeq” (Heb.: horizon in sight) held at the Eshkol Hall earlier this week.
Besides circle members Nahshi, Shmulik, Oded, Radir, Hanan, and Hayuta, Malki and Uzi also brought Bella with them from Gvulot. There were exciting, interesting guests: Noga brought Shaul with her – she from Tel Aviv, he from Ramat Gan. Shaul presented a position according to which he proposes to live in ‘fraternity’ with our enemy. This is how we shall learn to respect our differences.
Adir from Sapir and Qtura spoke beautifully about his wish as a child to go to Jordan, and the power of innocence which is the ultimate partner of hope.
Mari came from Beit Elazari and treated us to great Beeri cheeses.
Murad and Wahib from Rahat came to look in on us for a few moments.
We were also empowered by Awad who came with Radir, Yossi and his son Uri who passed by and expressed their empathy and sympathy, Bella charmed us with her open-heartedness and different personal story, and towards the end we eagerly wited for Osa, the film director, and Vivian from Beeri who brought Osa to us. Osa told us about the film and his wish to see people from both sides.
Radir connected us by phone with Rami who remained in Jordan, for Israel does not allow him to return to the country in spite of having a permit to move inside it unhampered. He was supposed to be with us today. What a pity.
Hayuta facilitated and enjoyed the occasion.
Lighthouse 91 – 13.12.2019
On Thursday, December 12, 2019, at 13:10, without any warning signs, a mad sandstorm broke out, filling the entire area with sand and dust clouds. Out of this storm Rami opened the Lighthouse circle on Friday, December 13. He spoke about camel caravans moving in the storm, navigating along an inner compass from Midyan (a giant oasis in the Saudi desert) towards Gaza, the city that has been the region’s most important and influential junction for many periods in history.
Rami was not alone, of course… Present were also Shmulik and Oded who came as always (91 weeks), and the camera crew from Sapir College’s film school, Or and Gal, were already waiting. They have been accompanying us for the second week now, and will probably arrive in the next ones as well.
While coffee was being poured, Roni joined us, with Adir. Jaber arrives and surprises us with his daughter Sirin.
Noga comes too, to photograph as well. So now we are surrounded with two video cameras, every word is recorded… This requires a ‘getting acquainted’ circle.
Rami facilitates. The usual members repeat the message of conscience that guides them, like that camel caravan in the sandstorm, to come to Migdalor (lighthouse) and raise their consciousness of Gaza, along with the fresh joiners and with the besieged Gazans.
As we speak about Gaza, we are joined by Nahshi, Limor and Moshe. They are all from Nir Yitzchak, along with furry, barking Yefet and Nina.
Or and Noga go from side to side in order to catch the various speakers in the circle. Naturally the circle’s rules apply to them as well, and their own awareness of Gaza adds itself to our circle.
Andrea and Dan arrive. These are Americans from Chicago, speaking excellent Hebrew. They have been sent by Ye’ela who also arrives after a few minutes, riding tandem with her daughter Shani. Later we will also be visited by Tomer, Ye’ela’s partner and Shani’s father.
Soli from Yevul village arrives as well as Marie from Beit Elazari.
This Friday Lighthouse circle included about 20 participants (not including Nina and Yefet).
Everyone spoke, they all shared their Gaza awareness, each from the place where Gaza meets them personally. Gal and Or of Sapir College had been soldiers in the 2014 military operation, Ye’ela resides a few hundred meters from the Gaza Strip houses, Sirin and Jaber live in an unrecognized village, Roni (at Rami’s request) repeats her story of transferring the piano to Gaza, Adir lives in Sderot but in his parents’ community he meets and speaks with Palestinian students who study there, and all of us – neighbors and residents of the same region – long for time and calm in order to heal the suffering taking place elsewhere on the planet.
Written by Oded
meeting no. 90 – December 6, 2019
Hardly were we on our way to the Migdalor meeting when a message came from Ghadir that she and Jaber were not coming. Shmulik went to the Dead Sea, Malki and Uzi were at a jazz festival, and Rami notified that he was at a photo shoot…
Who? What? Nahshi and I come to Beeri and meet three students of the Sapir College. They are second year communications students, armed with documentation equipment. They’re making a film for their studies. Or (guy), Or (another guy) and Shani (girl). They follow us to the Migdalor meeting at the sulfur plant.
As usual we arrange a circle. Now it’s even documented… Rami comes, coffee as well (brought by Nahshi, who else…) and there are also Mark, Roni, Nomika, Nur and Hanan.
Finally for the last hour Mirale and Neta from Be’eri also arrive. At this time Rami reviews the rationale behind the Migdalor (lighthouse) project to the camera and microphone placed in front of him by the film students.
Nahshi says of himself that until some time ago he was “floating” in the suppressed mode until he realized “something was wrong” and began to be active.
I have something to say too, and I say it…
Rami does not give the students a break, although they act as being immersed in their project, and asks them to take part in the discussion circle. They come from Ramle, Kiryat Ono and Bat Yam. Beyond their assignment, Gaza arouses their curiosity, they took part as soldiers in the 2014 military actions. One of them he “abstains”. We wonder, he explains. He avoids thinking about Gaza because it is a complex tangle of struggles, intrigue and insoluble conflicts.
Mark who is presently much busier with the climate struggle stretches his vision from Gaza to the entire planet.
Roni brings the discourse back to the simple people on both sides of the fence and tells about the friend who managed to come out of Gaza and is on his way to meet the Dalai Lama in India! On his way, he paid her a visit. He crossed over at the Erez Checkpoint, at Netiv Ha-Asara, on a bus from Ashqelon, visited a friend in Jerusalem, went to Jericho, from there to Jordan, and from there took a plane to India.
Hanan tells about his Buddhism studies and how they are tied with his feelings about the goings-on in Gaza.
Nur, always touching our feelings, does it again as she says that she tells herself about a girl her own age, also called “Nur”, who lives in Gaza and cannot do the simple things that she, Nur from Sderot, can do. Although the Gazan Nur is someone whom the Israeli Nur has invented, she knows there are many real “Nurs” in Gaza who suffer from the ongoing siege.
Nomika was not eager to speak but still, somewhat tired, speaks about the declarations that are repeated again and again without managing to change reality.
Mirale remembers Khaled who had worked in Be’eri, that “he and Rami actually grew up together” on the kibbutz grounds.
Then a conversation ensues about the future of the world, and notions such as “extinction rebellion” and “9 billion humans in the world”, “2 million in Gaza”, “Yuval Noah Harari” are mentioned. There is no argument about the concepts and facts, there are only optimism and pessimism…
Clearly here, at the “Lighthouse”, even the pessimists continued – secretly – to be optimists and act for the present and the future of the nearby space and beyond… and it’s now all photographed.
In the meantime we received a video record of the encounter with the Dalai Lama! Hopefully soon in our parts…
Okay. It’s 4 p.m. Time to go home.
Oded
29.11.2019
Migdalor (Lighthouse) meeting no. 89
November 29, 2019
So, who and what did we have with us today at the meeting?
Present were Miri and Ilana from Nirim, Roni, Jaber, Malki and Uzi, Oded, Nur who brought her parents, Rotem and Yermi, Talila, Uri and Tomer – their lovely son, and Yigal from Be’eri.
What else was there:
Roni and Oded told us about yesterday’s encounter in Ramallah, which was attended by many people.
Roni excitedly told us about her meeting Fatma. Fatma and Roni maintain phone contact. Fatma is like Roni in Gaza. They have never actually met. The hug we witnessed and Roni’s excitement made Jaber’s skin tingle. Furthermore, Rami, our contact person in Gaza, told us this was a meeting not of two women but of two peoples! Roni wiped her tears.
Brave Nur intends to publish a journal shared by Gazan and Israeli youth which would have a common theme.
Miri spoke about her frustrating work in Bedouin schools.
Yermi told us about a wondrous relationship with the children of two Bedouin villages.
And there was coffee, and pleasantness and it was all as important as always.
Hayuta was impressed.
1.11.2019
November 1, 2019
Not nice – my film was interrupted… They said there was an alert in the whole region and “we’re not taking any risks”. It might reach us too. So I went home. TV has “breaking news”. Too bad, it seemed like a good film (Almodobar). A few hours ago I was at another “film”, at “The Lighthouse” with friends. A family from Ra’anana came on bicycles (Ruti, Amikam, Metzada and Yoad). They enjoyed the unusual hospitality of the circle people (who came early and enjoyed coffee that had “almost” boiled…) and were impressed by our explanations and the pictures on the “factory” wall. We began an introductory circle, and when Ruti’s turn came to speak Amikam spoke up and said that we had not spoken politics but he (immediately) understood which side we were on and they are on the other side… Ruti begged to differ and said that she didn’t exactly agree. Metzada was a bit shy (2nd grade) because she “doesn’t know about Gaza” and Yoad (apparently in high school) said that for him Gaza meant what one hears in the media. They had to return their bikes until 2 p.m. and hurried to leave. We remained – Shmulik, Oded, Nahshi, Oa and Hanan. The latter three began to plan a media setup that would accompany “The Lighthouse” project. Shmulik kept silent (finally a subject – internet – he is willing to admit he knows nothing about) and I tried to convince the water to boil (Rami had taken his good gas burner with him on a trip to the desert) for lukewarm coffee is undrinkable. Jaber arrived and Yig’al immediately after him. A communication infrastructure was set up for our project (on paper) and the water boiled. The majority decided to speak with the circle’s friend in Gaza. Vivian arrived (on foot from Be’eri!). Jaber translated his friend’s words from Gaza. Booms were heard in the background. Well-tuned hearers also mentioned volleys. Between booms and volleys we spoke with Gaza. They heard it too. As for me, this was perhaps the most interesting conversation we have held to date. About parents and family, lots of self-humor, exposing the person himself, where he comes from, where his parents come from, what are his fears, his hopes… We “dared” to express some interest in the more intimately personal stuff (intimate meaning relative to a question like “tell us a bit about the group’s activity…”) and we also laughed together. Jaber was sharp enough to translate even comments that sounded a bit cynical… Time went by and it was already 4:30 p.m. No more daylight saving time and an early sunset. It’s hard to stop as more and more subjects for talking and asking questions arise. But… Bye now, the “film” is over, it’s back to reality in “Gaza space”, and definitely not nice that this evening my film was cut short…
18.10.2019
October 18, 2019
The last day of our “neighborly and peaceful sukkah (tabernacle)”.
Present were: Rami, Radir, Jaber, Roni, Shmulik, Oded, Rafi, Mark, Danny, Dovale, Ravit, Rotem, Nur, Yermi, Moshe, Tzvika, Tami, Diti, Vered, Gali, Maharan, Rami (Gaza), Maram (Gaza, poet in Arabic and English), Abed al Rahman (Gaza), Ahmad (Gaza), Alaa (Gaza, a musician), Uzi, Malki, Vivian, Bella, Ofer, Ye’ela, Eti, Yael, Moshe.
A family from Segev Shalom (a man with his 2 wives and 2 daughters) came near the end of the encounter and I did not get their names…)
Places of residence: Sderot, Gvulot, Jerusalem, Kfar Saba, Ashkelon, Nir Yitzchak, Al Zarnuk, Rahat, Beer Sheva, Be’eri, Alon Ha-Galil, Netiv Ha-Asara, Alumim, Urim, Gaza, Yesha, Kisufim. (Where did Malki’s family come from? Can’t remember, but we can add another place…) The height of the meeting was an hour-and-a-quarter long conversation with five Gazans, one of them a woman who writes poetry, and who read us an English poem. Most of the questions asked of them by the participants physically present dealt with their daring to express themselves in public and expose their contact (by phone) with Israelis.
Many of the circle participants used the notions “optimistic – pessimistic” today (“pessimistic” had the upper hand…) and in spite of their appreciation of “The Lighthouse” initiative, their expectation of change depends on the leaders, not the people (namely, “The Lighthouse” is nice but has no effect). For most of the participants in the circle Gaza is a place of pain and pity. As for “blame”, “people” are divided between either fully blaming Israel, fully blaming Gaza, fully blaming everyone, and fully blaming the leaders. To its very last moments, the “circle” continued to arouse curiosity and interest. Using the musical term, we ended with a long ‘crescendo’. The circle did not die down but continued to grow in vitality as closing time (4 p.m.) grew near. Finally, the end… Thanks to whom? Everyone! Really, every single one. The initiators, the participants, the operative team and the planners, the discussion facilitators, the coffee makers, the guests who were physically present, the guests who took part by phone, and the facebook people. The production is a collaboration of “Another Voice” and “The Lighthouse”.
In my years in the theatre I learned that the show takes place not on stage not in the auditorium but in the space created between the stage and the audience. Similarly, “Gaza awareness” is not anyone’s private matter. It is created in the space between the speaker and the hearer, and this space grew and grew with every speaker who was listened to.
That’s it. We now continue as usual on Fridays between 1 and 4 p.m.
Many thanks to everyone!
16.10.2019
October 16, 2019
About 50 women and men passed through our sukkah (tabernacle) today! Instead of naming them, I shall list where they came from… So – Be’eri, Netiv Ha-Asara, Nir Yitzchak, Gvulot, Al Zarnouk, Beit Hashmonai, Sa’ad, Gedera, Zimrat, Sderot, Netivot, Tel Aviv, Gaza (by phone), Urim, Haifa, Jerusalem and Mevaseret Zion. This is certainly an impressive variety. The circle peaked with a discussion led by Gili Zivan of Kibbutz Sa’ad, in which she iterated the meanings of this holiday in Jewish ethos as well as the interpretations of various philosophers over the years. Among the dozens of people crowded on the white plastic seats were also 9 girls of different families. Noa, Alma and Tahel of Bet Hashmonai, TEhila, Hadasa and Naomi of Netivot, and Chen, Adi and Hadar of Mevaseret Zion. I mention them because nearly all these sweet and talented girls concentrated their energy in drawing the “stars” (of hope) and expressed their view of Gaza through their art. Our Khalil, the coffee artist, drew a “star” and stuck it to the wall of our structure with a nail. The views of adults sitting in the circle reflected the views common in the country, with the general tendency of “blaming” Hamas and the Gazans who do not rise up and resist, and compassion for them and … ourselves for having to suffer… When everyone took leave of the “circle”, everyone expressed their appreciation for this project. It is exhausting, indeed, but fascinating and shows especially how people wish to meet, express their opinions and listen to others while “respecting” the rules of the “circle”, without pointless arguments and harsh words. I believe that the circular, orderly “structure” of the discussion enables a more “refined” manner which elsewhere sound “violent” when voiced in competitive arguments. That’s it. Finally, when Rami and I remained, “packing” our equipment (did you know that all of it was “loaned” by Rami’s storehouse?) and the sound of the meeting fading in the distance died down and made room for the site’s natural quiet, we knew that today was (another) especially special day.
Hello world!
Welcome to WordPress. This is your first post. Edit or delete it, then start writing!