Encounter 254 – 20.1.2023

Apparently, stormy days, winter in full swing, demonstrations in the face of political/legal/social chaos, crazy communication, a sense of the end. in fact, everything is “for now”. The winter days are warm, the demonstrations are only on the weekend and the chaos is brewing and will be served in February. Communication? The majority say that they no longer connect to the frequency…
and us? Here we are an island of stability. We position ourselves every Friday like a cuckoo clock that Gaza appears in the window and announces our disgrace and the disgrace of the world. Here There is actually a feeling of no end. Positively and negatively. Positively, because we are here every Friday and negatively, because the human anomaly occurring in Gaza has no end.
A lot of people arrived today. The list below will reflect maybe a fifth of the actual participants.
At first we were Nahshi, Moshe, Shmulik, Mark and myself, then a couple from the area arrived and at two o’clock about 40 travelers flocked to their guide and microphone. They were sure that we were some kind of surprise that the guide had prepared for them. At the same time Malki, Rami, Mirale, Uzi, Deganit, Bella, Ovadia and Roni also arrived! Yes yes our friends Roni took a cane, Ovadia and a matching chair and came back to be with us after (so and so) a long time.
The guide told the group (from the Avshalom Institute) about sulfur and history, I told about us and Rami continued and talked about history, about grandparents, Rotenberg and Tel Hai (respectively) childhood near the border fence and about hope. The group was intrigued and wanted to sit more, they had many more questions, but the guide… they left.
The immediate family remained and Rami feels that the situation “requires” Gaza awareness.
Nahshi told about his friend who is a documentary filmmaker. Yesterday they met for coffee. In 2005, the friend made a film about Gaza with Haim Yavin. They were interviewing some leaders and Chaim Yavin wanted to go talk to people in the market. The security guards were stressed. Chaim Yavin calmed down and said they would introduce themselves as a German TV crew (he knows German). The security guards agreed. They went to the market and all the merchants said “Oh, Chaim Yavin has arrived!”.
Bella doesn’t know how much is known about us. The silence scares her. I don’t know how to predict our future. I always think about them. I take care for them like I take care for us.
Moshe says that his concern is no longer focused only on our space. Now, the country is in danger. The dominant language is violence. It is tangible and sharp, something existential, really physical. What is happening now is not temporary. A struggle is needed.
Mirale wants to maintain her mental health and therefore does not watch/listen to the media, “a bit playing the ostrich” according to her. She is aware and talks about the absurdity of the surrounding pastoralism compared to the reality in the territories.
Roni thinks that sometimes it might be better to disconnect, but she can’t, she is constantly interacting with people and needs to know. To ease the mental burden a little, she focuses on knowledge about Gaza. Mainly with the help of her friends there. updating Who left Gaza and moved to the big world and who stayed. She feels she has to help them. There are many changes. Laborers are coming out and this is a big change for the better in Gaza and it is also expressed quietly here. She gets a lot of requests for help getting out. She met with the director of the border terminal in Erez and found there a great willingness to help. She is in contact with a Dutch psychologist who enters Gaza and meets with psychologists and sociologists for workshops and support.
Ovadia says that Gaza reminds him how unwise we are. In the past he walked there alone in many places and was treated with great respect. What is happening today is because of us because we did not understand what was happening there and spoiled it for several generations. When some whispering embers appeared we could put them out before they started a big fire and we did the opposite, we lit them instead of putting them out. A sense of greatness and arrogance brought us to the current situation. We would free them from the burden of Egypt. Here we can still demonstrate against evil and crime. There are those who suppress such demonstrations.
Daganit says she doesn’t know Gaza like we do. She is here because of Rami and it moves her to support the idea. She is not one who often goes to demonstrations, to say the least. And if she was at a demonstration and in the pouring rain, that means all the summers are over! I really relate to the things said here. I remember that as a child she rode a bicycle in Gaza and it was fun.
Uzi precedes and says that he is very happy to come and see Rami enthusiastic and lecturing – a sign that he is healthy! Also happy to see Roni and Ovadia. Read last week the book “The Conspiracy Against America” written by Philip Roth. Didn’t know the book. A dystopia, a novel that simulates an alternate history of America with Charles Lindbergh supposedly defeating Roosevelt in the 1940 election. Lindbergh was a glorified pilot, anti-Semitic, white supremacist, Nazi sympathizer. In the book there are Jews who (supposedly) collaborate with him and he has plans to “treat” the Jews. In the book there is a description of a reality that is similar to what is happening around us today.
Malki ponders aloud and asks what has changed in her since she came here the first time. Is her look different? “No” she says, this place gave expression to the feeling she came with. Sometimes it’s nice to be an ostrich. But if there were no demonstrations and everyone would continue as usual? The demonstration gives a feeling that many people think like her, it gives hope even if nothing changes and Gaza continues to be a great despair. Our place gives her strength.
Shmulik says that what he can do in the personal sphere, he does. From conversations with a friend from Gaza, he knows that the situation there is dire. Today’s peace is thanks to those who pass and work. Things need to be resolved.
Suddenly, about 15 curious young people peek out from all the openings. They are invited for coffee (even though it is already a quarter to four). They came from Tarabin near Gvaot Bar. Some are shy, some accept the offer of coffee. Rami tries to get them to talk about Gaza. Only a Abed is willing to say that his mother is from there and that he has a family there, but he himself has no connection. A little more talk about (lack of) employment opportunities in their settlement.
There was also Amos who was walking with his grandchildren and said that at the age of five and a half he went down with another boy older than him to the bottom of the well in the sulfur factory! 51 meters!
He added that the current appearance of the building was caused by the departure of the British when anyone who could get their hands on something of value and sell it, did so.
At a rough estimate there were 60-70 people at the lighthouse today
Who was? A very, very partial list: Mirale, Roni, Ovadia, Daganit, Uzi, Malki, Shmulik, Rami, Oded, Nahshi, Bela, Moshe, Mark, Salman, Abed.
Written by: Oded

Encounter 253 – 13.1.2023

A week ago a lot of people came and we felt that we are at the beginning of a wonderful friendship with the migration season of the people in the Be’eri reserve. Even today, a beautiful day without rain, the area is covered with green. Here and there begins some red marks of flowers. However, despite the promise contained in the above description, many travelers in the area are not predicted.
Those who did come (to walk) were Lital and Eyal who were captured by Nahshi’s charismatic invitation and came for coffee and teasing.
Lital has memories. She was born in a kibbutz on the Gaza border. She remembers the 1967 war, 3 days in the shelter. Father is a cotton man and was also involved in the security field. She was 7 years old. Someone from the kibbutz was killed at the very beginning. The Kibutz organized the children to prepare a reception for soldiers returning from the battles in Sinai. Convoys of buses arrived, but with Egyptian prisoners – there were no Israeli soldiers. She cried because she was waiting for soldiers and not prisoners. Father said that’s how it is in war, there are prisoners, nothing will be done to them and they will return home. Then workers began to arrive and people began to travel in Gaza. Lital remembers being overwhelmed by the friendly reception they received in Gaza. I remember the pots alley and Ali Monter. In her military service she came again to Ali Monter and remembered. Now she lives in Tel Aviv and everything is far away, the childhood, the memories, Gaza too. We do not know what is happening with those who worked for us, I only know that they were not allowed to return to work. Today she went for a walk with her brother in the area and suddenly realized that “she can be seen from there” and maybe it is a bit dangerous. (This is how it is when you get too used to Tel Aviv). People live here and people live there, she concludes and asks, how will all this end? She wants to ask us if we are actively doing something in the area? How can you influence? Who cares?
Eyal says that for him Gaza is… “I don’t want to define it”. He knows it well, he is Lital’s older brother and still lives in the kibbutz where they were born. Claims that he is so radical to the left that he reached Ben Gvir. (Lital is horrified. “Don’t write it” she says). Eyal says that he helped someone from the Gaza village hang a joint photo exhibition of her and artists from Gaza and we all remember that Batya (the photographer) sat in a circle with us and told about the exhibition, small world. After that, Eyal turns to Kai (we’ll get to know him soon) and tells him that he hosted two guests from Norway and took them to the “Black Arrow” to look over Gaza and also emphasized to them that only from here can you see and understand what Gaza really is and that you don’t have to believe the “brainwashing” that the Palestinians do to the Europeans in the media abroad.
Kai has been in Israel for several years, a musician plays double bass, lives in Jerusalem and trying to become an Israeli citizen (his father is Israeli). Kai was born in the USA, grew up and lived in Norway, until he came to study and play in Israel. Kai says that Gaza is an interesting place. But more interesting is the ability of people in Israel to ignore their neighbors. He himself lives in Abu Tor – a mixed neighborhood of Jerusalem.
Rami calls and the conversation with Kai is cut off, unfortunately non-renewable
Rami wishes a happy new year and hopes for new beginnings. He wants to have coffee with us. The conversation with him is also blurring until it is disconnected.
Hayuta feels that Lital’s questions were not answered. She tells Lital that she herself did not come here with a plan to change anything, she has no ambitions to influence, just to add her little toothpick to the fire of hope.
Nahshi continues the line of Hayuta and says that he came here to keep himself from changing and to remind himself that close to him are people who are suffering. He has no idea what the solution will be. If there is any contribution to the hospitality of people here, it is to make it clear that there are people there and here. They are indeed led by a powerful body (“soon with us” he says) but still, people are people and they have rights and desires to exercise.
Lital works at the Haaretz Museum and organized a tour for the workers committee. They arrived at Alumim and the people were a bit in shock from the proximity to the border. Until then, they didn’t really understand the situation of being near Gaza.
4 young women and men pass, two+two. They try to slip away and continue, but Nahshi’s charisma and Shmulik’s promise to go through the production line for tea instead of coffee sat them down. They want to know the history of the place and I tell. At the end of the historical description, I tie in the theme of the “Lighthouse” and ask them to share with us “What is Gaza for them?”. silence. After a few seconds one mumbles that he has no interest in politics. Neither do we, I say, only humans. He says he also saw someone taking pictures of them and he asks not to publish. Well, says Nahshi, I deleted. They are suspicious and refuse to even say their names, except that they are from Jerusalem. But the tea is served, so one of them opens with a short speech and this is what I managed to write down:
give me peace get peace I considered coming to live in the south. Is it worth it for me to come and live in the south? If it’s quiet, sure, but leaving the house every time when something happens? Do not want. I don’t deal with politics. I have friends of all religions and I have visited Arab friends in their homes, but if you come to stab me I will cut off contact. Israel is attacked by Gaza and that’s where politics starts and it’s none of my business. Obviously, as people, they suffer, but we have no solution.
One of the boys also briefly and quickly says the following (not before his friends emphasize that he is a bereaved brother):
I don’t trust them. I will not turn my back on them because they will stick a knife in me. They killed my friend’s father when he went to the market. Give them a finger and they will want the whole hand. Terrorism in Gaza. Don’t trust them.
After these things they get up and go – they have to return to Jerusalem before Shabbat.
Mahran, who arrived in the meantime and listened to the conversation, says that his instinct says that “the two” are policemen and that is why they were so reserved and that his instinct is not wrong. Maybe.
For me, in any case, a feeling of discomfort from this quartet remained for a while, a feeling that continued even after they left.
We were: Hayuta, Shmulik, Nahshi, Moshe, Kai, Oded, Lital, Eyal, Maor, Mir, Mahran, 4 Jerusalemites who did not want to say their names.
Written by: Oded

Encounter 252 – 6.1.2023

First meeting of the new year. A guided group descends from private vehicles, watches us from the high level and glides towards the well. I “ambush” them there and invite them to the circle.
They listen and settle down. I’m cutting history short (I hope it’s “short”, at least I’m trying). From me to the left, where Itzik is sitting.
Itzik recalled that he used to cross Gaza on the coastal road, where he had clients. Gaza seemed to him like a big refugee camp.
Esther: Gaza is a miss. The money that goes there is directed less to the well-being of the residents and more to the well-being of Hamas.
Tal is impressed by the overcrowding and poverty and also tells about a carpenter from Gaza, very professional, who made him furniture for the house.
Dina was during her military service at a near base. At that time, Gaza was open and she spent most of her time in Yamit and Gaza.
Orly says that Gaza is overcrowding and poverty that hostile factors have taken over. A place of waste.
Amotz also uses the word “missing” to describe the feeling about Gaza (the word will come up again and again later on). He had Gazan employees in the past.
Orit remembers a visit to Khan Yunis, she was not afraid. Could have been good, miss.
Isabel: Her father served for many years in Gaza. She had friends there. Now that’s a miss.
Sefi was an operations officer. He has a lot of memories from Gaza. I managed to write down that he remembers children who sell sabers and refugees that we are responsible for part of their emissions. In his opinion, there is nothing to do with their ideology.
Fabian remembers spending Saturdays in Gaza. Lived and Served in the army then in Yamit. Gaza is a cursed place for her. Her three sons were there in the military service. From 2014 it is a different and distant place.
Avi remembers Abu Hatira’s fish restaurant on the beach. His first bicycle was bought for him in Gaza.
Nirit says that when she was a child she went with a family friend, a military man, to visit Gaza. They went in a Mercedes and he had a gun in the car. They went into all the sweets shops in Jiblia.
Ronit’s daughter served in the army in Nahal Oz and Kerem Shalom. The majority there, in Gaza, want peace. She wants to be optimistic and quietly adds, “If we have a country left.”
Roni led delegations of donors to visit the Shaar HaNegev Regional Council. She was very impressed by the principal of the school who worked hard to educate the students not to hate. She think of children on both sides who during the “rounds” are looking for an immediate hiding place.
Oded also connects with the statement of miss. He see no hope. The younger generations do not know either side. Mainly there, there are more and more people who want revenge.
Udi says Gaza is a tragedy. He knows Jews, descendants of Jews from Gaza. Extremists navigate politics and control and these are the results. They are held captive by a gang. Udi hopes we are not in the same direction.
Yotam (the group’s guide) spent a lot of time in Gaza. It almost cost him his life. A friend of his from the army was killed and since then he keeps in touch with the friend’s mother. The mother lives in a Kibutz near Rahat and has a good relationship with a family from Rahat, one of whose daughters married someone from Gaza who has been avoiding visiting his family for many years. During the couple’s visit to her home, their little son saw pictures of the fallen son and promised the mother that when he grows up, he will buy tanks and planes and take revenge on whoever killed her son.
Yehuda thinks that Gaza is a wasted potential for both sides, but we have no choice and they have to be flexible.
Orli says that Gaza is a “great sorrow”. The uninvolved population is held captive by Hamas. They are brought up to see us as enemies. Hopefully one day we will think the other way around and instead of shelling, we will choose to improve their lives. Maybe it will help a life together.
Avi was in Gaza for the first time in 1967 after the war. He was a boy who was walking with his father. Gaza is the essence of the conflict and life in Israel. There should be hope but it’s hard to see the light.
Danny was in Gaza for the first time at the age of 17. They made a bicycle trip from the north to the settlement of the maritime zone south of the Gaza Strip. In the past he supported the evacuation but today he thinks it should have been part of an agreement to resolve the conflict. Today, the parties can no longer do anything. You can sit in the “Lighthouse” and talk about, but there is nothing to do and it’s a shame.
Tali said that her father was also in Gaza and so was her son. Tali was an officer in the Yamit evacuation, a difficult experience. She see in this place a soured paradise because of those pulling the strings. She is also connected to Gaza through her journalistic work. She spent quite a few times of violence here, was a participant in personal conversations with Gazans in which they told her their tragedy and also a lot of aggression and anger. There is a lot of missing here. There may be a desire to improve, but also helplessness and it’s depressing.
Mark raised his children at a time when they were riding the bus to school and there were shelling. The children were trained in survival instructions. Today his children live in Tel Aviv and do not want to start their families here. There is a lot of food for thought not only for this region, but for the whole country. The conversations here, at the “Lighthouse”, challenge Mark’s most basic values and his civic duties. The place helps him think.
Uzi is frustrated like everyone else with what is happening and what is not happening. Want to influence in some way and bring hearts together. Tells about the release of pigeon to freedom project that he conceived and continues to promote (physical flying and virtual flying). He hopes that the very act of releasing the pigeon from captivity will bring a message of bringing hearts together. He also added an electronic sign that would name each pigeon release, and display the number of participants. To illustrate, Uzi brought a pigeon in a small cage, and it was released to the applause of the spectators and the ticking of the cameras.
The group left and we were left alone. Shmulik tells about the meeting with the “Be’er Ora” preparatory school that took place on Monday in Nir Yitzhak. I say that my impression is that they know almost nothing about Gaza, and worse, Gaza is of no interest to them. At the meeting, they were a little pushed to talk out of necessity and to comment, but not out of desire.
Ilan says that young people have a lot of stimuli and there are many other areas that do not interest them, not only Gaza.
Vivian says that the reluctance to know about Gaza does not depend on age.
Mahran says that teenagers are interested in Messi and Ronaldo and the smartphone. This is where an internal Israeli political debate is developing about the new government’s moves. It is true that among the circle’s members today there are representatives of the variety of opinions in the Israeli empirical space, but no opinion is surprising in its originality and therefore, due to the length of the summary, we will skip it.
Family is coming: They came from the north for the weekend in the south which is starting to bloom.
Uri also comes.
Mark explains about us and starts another round.
Moshe: The circle is always open to guests. We want to listen. Listening to people from Gaza and beyond. People ask us, “Are there also people like you on the other side”? Yes, says Moshe, we (and others) establish contact and conduct dialogue whenever possible. It is also a component of his desire to be here at the lighthouse.
Eitan thinks that even if Hanin Zoebi becomes Prime Minister, nothing will change. Israel’s military capabilities are insane and the Palestinians have no ability to do anything to us for another century. Therefore, the attacks they carry out do not advance them and only strengthen the Israeli right. The only chance for them to change, is to come and ask for peace.
Carmel, a student in the 8th grade, is surprised when it is suddenly her turn to speak. I don’t understand anything about the subject, she says, at school they don’t deal with the subject.
Moran does not look at the same level as Eitan. On a daily basis she doesn’t think about Gaza, it makes her sad. Her son will be serving there soon. A political solution is not in sight. Against the background of her son’s service, which is approaching operational activity, she decided to learn more about the conflict.
A colleague, a soldier, is finishing a route soon. “I don’t have anything smart to say,” he says. In the army he trains for war and thinks to do it well. If there is a situation where he enters Gaza, he is almost certain that he will not spare any means when he encounters the enemy, but I wish it would not happen and he would not have to deal with such a situation.
Ran is a 12th grade student. He says that people are not interested in the news. He knows that there in Gaza people live in hardship and poverty. When he was in the 11th grade, he remembers that they learned in class about deportation during the War of Independence.
Uri understands Ran and feels the same way.
Mahran, perhaps in response to what he said to Eitan, says that the situation is serious and the world is very pragmatic and fast. Everyone has abilities. We are exposed to the changes that will happen around us. Where there is occupation there is resistance. He has an Israeli Jewish friend whose son is a soldier and he is anxious like everyone else.
Vivian told about a meeting she organized between Israeli and Palestinian women’s groups. The Palestinians were shocked when they heard the Israelis talking about peace. She tells Eitan that it features the side that tightens the plunger and she wants to open it. He does talk about absolute Israeli military superiority, but they, with balloons and kites, disrupted our lives and will do so as long as we occupy. Once, when it was still possible, Vivian took her children to meet her partners in Gaza and they “discovered” to their surprise, they were human beings and not enemies.
Mark tells about his son who served in the Armored Corps and because he was under pressure did not participate in one of the wars here in the region. He wishes his fellow soldier to take good care of himself and adds that the situation is very bad for the Israelis and it is terrible what happened to them. People should know what we do he says, every child should learn about it at school. We de facto control the territories and administer apartheid systems. He, Mark, is not ready to be a citizen of a country that runs its life in this way. Even if it is in the name of our security, we need to initiate the change, mainly for ourselves. We don’t have another hundred years. The people who grow up here will think that it is normal to live in such a country. This will be a reason for a big war.
Uri disagrees, overwhelmingly, with what Mark said. To his delight he discovered that there are Zionist Arabs who want to participate in Jewish life here and vote for Netanyahu. In the end, he says, 99% of the residents of the State of Israel are united in striving for the same thing and there is a desire for peace. Even language in the circle has differences of opinion. Everyone should join the army and be together. In relation to Canada, our situation is bad and in relation to Syria, our situation is good, he concludes.
And these are our names: Itzik, Esther, Tal, Dina, Orli, Amotz, Isabel, Sefi, Orit, Fabian, Avi, Nirit, Ronit, Roni, Oded, Udi, Yotam, Yehuda, Orli, Avi, Danny, Tali, Eitan, Moran, Amit, Ran, Carmel, Uri, Vivian, Mark, Shmulik, Mary, Ilan, Moshe, Nahshi, Itzik, Uzi, Mahran, Oded.
Written by: Oded.

Encounter 251 – 30.12.2022

Up the road to the “Lighthouse” 3 cars drove ahead of us. Nice, I told Shmulik, there are travelers. In the parking lot we found out that in the cars there were 7 dear women from the “Women Wage Peace” movement who had come with deliberate intent to our Lighthouse. We arranged the chairs in a circle, Shmulik at the tea stand (maybe for the first time since the “Lighthouse” was founded, the tea was prepared before the coffee!) and Rebecca, who has already visited several times, asks me to tell about ourselves “because there are some who still don’t know the Lighthouse” (yes, it’s hard to believe, but it’s a painful fact, there are some who don’t know yet about the “Lighthouse”).
I told, I answered some questions, we discovered mutual acquaintances, from our field of occupation and the fabric of our lives (Because it is the Israeli nature to immediately discover common acquaintances, and we are all in the same circle of active in the matter we are dealing with). When I talked about Rami, Batya, who is both one of the peace-making women and a resident of the area, began to tell about a project that Rami was involved in:
Batya lives close to the fence, and has been photographing the area for many years. Sometimes, she points her camera towards Gaza as well. At some point she had the idea of holding an exhibition of her photographs. She thought that if you were going to present an exhibition that examines one side of the fence, it might be worth combining it with photography enthusiasts from the other side of the fence. Posted on the Internet, and received several responses. Also a response from a Dutch doctor from the organization “Physicians for Human Rights” who occasionally entered Gaza. Contact was made with Rami who interested several local photographers. Some got “cold feet” and did not want to continue the relationship. one remains. Batya will “host” his photographs at the exhibition. They exchanged pictures and Batya says that there are pictures that really complement each other. For example, the same place is photographed by her from the direction of Israel and by him from the direction of Gaza. Batya says that the thought that they are so close and so far – is frustrating. The photographer really wants to go to the exhibition but can’t. The exhibition is voluntarily promoted by a large advertising agency that has joined the project.
In the meantime Mark, Vivian, Malki and Bella joined the circle. Unfortunately, after Batya’s words, the women of peace decided to go on their (long) journey back to their homes in the north. They came to us after they had already frequented the Friday circuit at “Black Arrow”.
We remained the regular and close. Vivian brought up the topic of the meeting that took place in the Misgav Regional Council, which was about taking advantage of the opportunity in the establishment of the new government to create a Jewish settlement in the Galilee, led by the Political right movements and with the participation of representatives of the kibbutz movement and the moshavim movement. The issue was published in an opinion column published by the journalist and writer Odeh Basharat in Haaretz newspaper. Vivian and several other people sent a comment to the paper. We hope it will be published in the coming days. It is possible that a petition will be signed against the move and everyone is invited to sign.
A discussion developed that expanded to other matters that emerge and multiply in the usurping “Zionist” context.
This time we were: Arna, Tamar, Edna, Rivka, Sigal, Batya, Chaya, Vivian, Bella, Malki, Mark, Oded, Shmulik.
Written by: Oded

Encounter 250 – 23.12.2022

Shmulik, Moshe, Hayuta and myself arrived and we stayed for about an hour and a half. Hayuta and I walked around the space trying to locate mobile chairs. At about half past two, a group of young women from the area arrived. A youth guide from a kibbutz in the area and with them 4 of their trainees, all graduates of the regional school. I mention the matter of the school because they immediately recognized me as “the one who taught street theater at school” and Shmulik as “the one who prepares potato chips”… (we both actually worked at the regional elementary school, until the outbreak of the Coronavirus).
The group sat down, treated themselves to coffee and bit into the yeast cakes they had brought with them. Although they live in the area, they had not heard of the “Lighthouse” so I explained about us. I tried to bring as much historical factual information as possible from the knowledge that we have accumulated over the years.
In my understanding, the unconsciousness that Jewish Israelis go through, the size of the education and media systems in Israel, in everything related to the indigenous people to the Palestinians, leaves the reference to the Palestinians to the realm of emotion only. That is why it is important to me to emphasize to the facts.
Moshe said that we are surprised anew every time people sit with us. We are open to listening to every opinion, he says and adds that he has an optimistic side that believes it is possible to have an impact.
Rotem deals with youth guidance. He says that Gaza is here, near his house. This situation, in his opinion, cannot continue. Need for solution. But a solution does not serve the leaders on both sides and therefore the situation does not improve.
Matan, one of the campers, says that Gaza is pressure. Gaza is such a fear.
Shani, instructor. She watched over Gaza in her military service. The first sentence that comes out of her mouth, “I love Gaza very much.” According to her, this is something that developed as a result of her military activity. Everyday she connected to their routine. farmers. come with the same working clothes… simple people. I “meet” with them every day and accompanied their lives for almost two years. You also see schools, children. It is clear who the enemies are and when… Hamas often thwarts activity against Israel, but this is also in accordance with its interests… the activity is routine, automatic, with almost no feelings involved. She really wants to visit the places she has been looking at. There were some demonstrations in front of the fence, but no shooting from our side. Hamas is everywhere, even if the majority does not support it, it is very embedded in the population.
Ma’ayan (camper)- Gaza is the enemy, that’s what he was taught all his life. It was not important for him, not even now, to challenge or reflect on this assertion…
Shmulik strongly supports the granting of work permits in Israel. He himself is involved in the employment of Gazans in Israel. It brings some calm in Gaza. There is no livelihood in Gaza and work relieves the stress a little. Our listening here to the different voices is also to create listening and connection with Gaza. We try as much as we can to help. My role as a person, Shmulik says, is to make it clear that life is not a newspaper headline. In reality, the personal connection between people leads to much more meaningful understandings and connections.
This week Hayuta dealt with David Grossman and the award he received. In a speech on the occasion of his victory, he declared himself a man of peace. The speech had a wide echo in the world. Grossman says that every effort should be made for peace. He quoted from Etty Hilsum’s book “The disrupted life” (Hayuta brought the book with her). Telling young people who Etty Hilsum was. She seeks to show a way from Hilsum’s teaching, that a relationship between people is important for creating reconciliation and understanding.
Yam (camper), asks Hayuta if she thinks that opening the fence in front of Gaza is realistic. In his opinion, opening the fence will cause them to come and kill us.
Rotem says that right now they have nothing to lose, so the direction is terrorism. It is important to give work to lower the motivation for terrorism. Make them understand that there are other options.
Shmulik says that the Gazans are between a rock and a hard place, nobody wants them. Not Israel, not Egypt and even the West Bank, seemingly among their own people, there is indifference towards them. The ability to trade and communicate outside of Gaza gives a perspective to a different life. A lot of Qatari money is reassuring too.
Yam repeats and tells Shmulik that he does not dispute that they want to live and deserve life, but they want it “at your expense”.
I summarize the discussion with the things I learned from Hillel Cohen’s book (facts, yes…) “Year Zero 1929”: After the disturbances in 1929, the British prosecuted those who they believed caused the outbreak. 29 of them (26 Arabs and 3 Jews) were sentenced to death by hanging. Without any reconciliation between them, the Arabs turned separately and the Jews separately to the British government and asked to pardon them all! The main argument in front of her, which, as mentioned, was not compatible, was that life together would slowly return to the normality in which it was conducted before and the executions would arouse renewed enmity. The British considered and begged for prison alternatives 26 of 29 The convicts. 3 (Arabs) were executed. By 1935 none of them remained in prison.
That’s it for today. The rain is already here and so is the cold.
We were: Moshe, Hayuta, Shmulik, Oded, Rotem, Shani, Matan, Ma’ayan, Yam and another one who walked around all the time with his dog and did not sit down with us.
Written by: Oded

Encounter 249 – 16.12.2022

Mary flew the lighthouse kite and two first guests ask what the star means. Tzachi came to us from Netivot. Golan is a resident of Moshav Shova.
Shmulik pours the first coffee, opens a circle and tells about the place, about the history of the old factory, including a rich description of the cavalry battle during the British occupation one hundred and five years ago. From there he skips to our time.
Golan and Tzachi add details about the space but emphasize that the belief in peace, equality and partnership in Shmuel’s words is far from their view. Nevertheless, they promise to return and part amicably. Mary, Mahran, Malki, Dina and Hanan join in a conversation of a more intimate nature because now the participants are the loyalists of the lighthouse, the “owners” according to the political language prevalent today…
Oded comes from a conference of “all citizens – al Moatiniha” party and updates on the discussions to establish a federation of equality as a basis for a new political partnership.
Rami enters, receives the blessing of those present and a cup of coffee. Rami shares with us his feelings regarding the transformations in Israel, in the immediate area and in his kibbutz. Rami’s words place another direction in the circle: the question of identity, personal and possibly also collective, in this world, in this time.
At four in the afternoon, a quarter of an hour before Shabbat begins, we fold the table that is falling apart (there is no whole from a broken heart, as above a broken table) and wish a happy Holiday of Lights, that the clouds of anger and darkness will disappear, in our days, at this time.
We were: Mary, Shmulik, Mahran, Malki, Dina, Hanan, Oded, Rami, Golan, Tzachi, Moshe.
Wrote: Moshe

Encounter 248 – 9.12.2022

Little by little, from week to week, more travelers are passing through the sulfur plant in preparation for the peak that will occur during “Southern Red”. Some of them went right through our circle and politely refused our invitation for coffee and friendly company for conversation. Only one couple asked if we would be there next week as well, today is already a little late for them because of the approaching Shabbat.
We were left alone.
The talk was about old age and recovery, until Jaber arrived.
Jaber was not long ago, so we held a circle of hugs (“only the empty chairs didn’t get up to hug me” he said). Then he was asked about his situation in the Travel Guide course. From the hesitation before he answered, we understood. Still he said a few things. He recalled that when he started the course, Shmulik told him, “They will fail you”. So while Jaber is getting close to the exams and is still in the course, he feels very well the difficulty of being an Israeli-Palestinian Arab who has to learn and explain the Jewish narrative only while ignoring and negating another narrative.
A discussion began in the circle. The sub-discourse dealt with the right claimed by the residents of the country, both these and those, for their possession of the space. The over-discourse sailed on talking about Zionism, about secondary and main currents in religions, about emotion, about truth and myth, and also about the question of whether Jaber should prepare for the tests as a “Jew” after passing a guide according to the best of his knowledge, or stick to the truth and the “non-academic” knowledge of His, even if it will result in failing the exams.
It was interesting, educational and… sweet! Sweet thanks to the Lin family’s decision to lower the sugar level in their home. A decision that earned us chocolate muffins and cookies brought by Mary.
As mentioned, the conversation worthy of a summary began only when Jaber arrived and since he felt that he had not yet exhausted the spirit of the “Lighthouse” in its entirety, Jaber remained to reflect on things in the parking lot, next to the car, with a fragrant hookah.
We were cold, it was a quarter past four and as our friend Jeff says from Rabbi Tarfon, “You do not have to finish the job and you are not free to withdraw from it ” (imagine that in an American accent). We went on to other crafts.
This time we were: Moshe, Malki, Bela, Mary, Hayuta, Jaber, Uzi, Nahshi, Oded.
Written by: Oded

Encounter 247 – 2.12.2022

The news heralded racism and robbery. We changed the radio station, first to Nablus Broadcasting and later to the Voice of Music, but the mood did not improve.
However, before we arrived at the lighthouse, we (Shmulik, Nahshi and Moshe) were treated to a Druze lafa with Labne.
The sky cleared and a pleasant sun illuminated our “winter residence”.
Shmulik just put the pot on the fire and the first circle has already opened with Abdal, Mahmoud and Farid, all three of the Tarabin tribe. First there was an explanation by Shmulik about the place and the meeting.
Farid told about his mother who came from Gaza, so we talked about the space, about neighbors near and far, about fears and hopes.
Roni called to inform about two German teachers making their way to the lighthouse:
Kristin and Brigitte came to us from the Bethlehem area. One teaches today and one in the past, at a school in the town of Beit Jala, and they shared with us their concern about the state of health in Gaza: there is a film documenting the hardships of cancer patients who need treatment. This time we preferred to skip the Yiddish and Nahshi managed to summarize, in English, the history of the sulfur plant.
Mark, also in English, completed the picture with an update on the current situation and his feelings.
We said goodbye to the visitors from Tarabin and Beit Jala and started another circle, with Limor, who was present at the weekly meeting of the “Hadar formation” for the return of the captives and the missing in the “Black Arrow” and with Mary, who contributed both insights into the complexity of the situation in the area and the fruits of her trees: delicious pecans.
At four o’clock in the afternoon, the evening wind blows, the hour of blessing and closing.
Writing: Moshe.
Documentation: Nahshi.

Special encounter – 29.11.2022

Through Nomika’s mediation, girls from the Tzali Preparatory School from Ein Tsurim, religious girls before conscription, came to us today in the early afternoon. We were part of their more extensive tour in the south and they came to us after a visit to Kibbutz Sufa. Nahshi brewed coffee and herbal tea. Rami donated chairs from his warehouse and moved them to the area, Julia and Maharan joined and I dug the opening with explanations about us, about the “lighthouse”, about the area, etc. (we know, we know).
After that, Julia spoke about the importance of each party’s recognition of the other, followed by Maharan (who came straight from his lawyer office, wearing a 3-piece suit and matching tie).
Shmulik and Nahshi joined the round with the girls and spoke in turn.
What then did the girls talk about? About “what is Gaza for them” of course, because that was our request.
And what did they say? Well, the majority chose answers that ranged from one to seven words. Here is what I managed to write down:
Gaza is something remote and scary
The word “Gaza” in itself causes fear
Terrorism
War, crime, bad things
Terror but also lack of choice
Remembering Gush Katif, disengagement, something that was taken from us, operations, poverty, a fence
Fear, enemies
War and fear
War and fear and hatred
Mutual injustice
All kinds of operations
Gaza is entering to the unknown
remembers in “cast lead” her man was almost killed. Big question mark, dead end, no solution
A lack of trust that hurts both parties
There are people living in Gaza who want to hurt me just because of my Jewishness
A problem without a solution
Bilateral impotence, no solution. I pity the Gazans who have nowhere to run
A complex situation. Heartache for the soldiers and residents. Also a little about the Gazans, a lot of misunderstanding
The words, coping, sacrifice, courage, understanding and hope come to mind
What does each side educate the children, does it love people, responsibility?
Fear and nightmares
The first thought in the context of Gaza is fear and sorrow for our soldiers and citizens
The kidnapped soldiers who did not receive a proper burial.
Heartache, fear and reluctance from the existing situation
The hope for peace following the expulsion from Gush Katif and the great suffering that come after.
I don’t feel sorry for those who live there but for those of us who suffer
Frustration and sorrow also regarding those there who live in poverty
Gaza reminds her of stories of her father who went there to the market and to the sea. Today it is anger and pain
Helplessness
Enemies, wars and frustration
Anger and frustration
I didn’t manage to write everything down, I didn’t necessarily hear every word (they speak weakly and I’m profoundly deaf).
I did not add here the wise and scholarly things voiced by my honorable colleagues, (the influence of Advocate Maharan) Shmulik, Nahshi, Julia and Maharan. After all, it’s a mid-week summary and I have a life too…
We were – Julia, Maharan, Shmulik, Nahshi, Oded
Transportation – Rami (go), Dagan (return)
Blessings – Moshe, Malki, Dina, Ye’ela, Limor, Hayuta, Eric, Roni, Nomika
Written by: Oded

Encounter 246 – 25.11.2022

We moved, we returned to the winter residence. Gather in the center of the sulfur factory building.
Seven men are sitting and discussing what happens to them after the first of November. The discussion leads to the question, “Why are we sitting here?” We decide to discuss it in a circular order as has been the custom at our “Lighthouse” for 4 years and 8 months.
Rami guides.
Moshe, who is honored to be the first in the round, admits that he is still a little shocked. He says that perhaps the others in the circle do not take, like him, seriously, the title that Ben Gvir receives in the position of Minister of “National Security”. Moshe, who has already experienced Argentina in the seventies, takes the addition of “national” seriously and anxiously. It is difficult for him with the movement of the (Jewish?) people to such a bad place. All the humanism of Agnon and Buber was erased. He has a suffocating feeling.
Nahshi says that he has nothing to add, but Rami doesn’t give up and Nahshi adds and adds! His first reaction after the election results was “Okay, we’ll manage in our corner, adapt, and let them screw up the business.” But maybe on second thought, he says, a state should be established elsewhere. Nahshi doesn’t feel comfortable just because his life is good. Interacting with people and feeling part of something bigger, gives a better feeling. Today his feeling is that he has nothing more to contribute at the state level. At the regional level closest to it (Gaza region) there is perhaps something to contribute, even if we are not at the center of public interest and the relationship with Gaza is local. The meetings here give him the opportunity to do something small that may have a little impact. Hope the Gaza issue will change. Perhaps, over time their current suffering will be eased with the processes of change in the region. As part of his dreams, he wants to establish a state in Gaza separate from Israel and also to live in it, but this will crowd Gaza even more… He has hope and faith in a better future for Gaza, but at the moment, he has no levers to hang his optimism on.
Shmulik says that there is definitely a reason as well as a result for our sitting here. Personally he will do what is in his power to do. Whether it’s helping with olive harvest, sitting at the lighthouse, donating to the Physicians for Human Rights Israel (PHRI) or helping people privately. In the general dimension, the more extreme the polarization, the more chance there is of an uprising. This is true throughout all social changes in history. This can happen with the help of external intervention (an asteroid in the case of the dinosaurs) Or wars. The polarization will lead to action. On a personal level, he says, he is doing things morally right.
I (Oded), who since my retirement often read and flaunt my new knowledge of old phenomena, cite two examples of how the combination of the emergence of a charismatic leader connected to the elite, into a polarized (class) situation caused powerful change processes. The first – Moses who grew up in the bosom of the Egiptian government and created a process of people’s migration (mass migration) that changed the reality of that people. The second – Theodore Herzl who, like Moses, also belonged to a local political elite and created a powerful process (whose results, for better or for worse, we still experience today). The context for the discussion is that the class polarization is deepening and the appearance of a charismatic leader (perhaps like Ben Gvir but the other way around) can cause a process of change. Shmulik throws aside that Hitler was also such a leader and I agree with him.
Rami cites as an example two events from the last few days. One is the incident of the stabbing to death of a man because he warned another person for crossing the crosswalk with his motorcycle at a red light and stabbed him and the second incident, a few days earlier when he and Naomi were returning at night from the north. They were driving on the highway and heavy truck drivers rioted on the road. Rami remembers that when he was younger, in his role as an Inspector with policing power, he used to stop drivers and warn them about dangerous driving or littering. Today he doesn’t anymore, he doesn’t dare. He prefers to ignore or stay away.
This week, Rami had to deal with a problem in his house. He contact a contractor. Two workers arrived, One from Ashkelon and one from Hebron. The balance of power quickly became clear. Talks started. Rami asked the Hebron man about his home and life and realized that the man was intelligent and learned. The Ashkelon man said there are no arguments between them and the Arab understands his place. Drink coffee and the conversation continued. The Ashkelon told the Hebronites that his daughter (of the Hebronites) had to learn Hebrew in order to survive in the region. Rami could claim that Arabic is important in order to survive in the space, but today’s Rami “does not encourage conflicts”. He also avoided going to certain places out of fear. Both in his home and anywhere in the country he feels unprotected and not at home. For him, he is ready to live anywhere in the world. The state distanced itself from him to the point of feeling of not belonging. He does not have a community with which it is possible to create change. In his work, he is involved in large initiatives and thinks that it may no longer be worth doing them in Israel. The West Bank and Gaza will not change in terms of status and maybe they, the world and we, will get used to it.
Mark says that the easiest thing is to say that he came here to meet friends. Mark arrived in Israel at an old age and did not have the opportunity to form friendships in settings that Israelis, the natives, are familiar with (school, army). The stage we reached, he says, was expected. The change was linear and not surprising in light of the last 20 years. His arrival here, in Israel, also required him to (mentally) join the Jewish people and not just change his place of residence. Realized that the Jews in Israel see themselves as a “light to the Gentiles.” He thought that he would not have to think about Judaism because it is normal, Judaism is the reality. Abroad, one had to make an effort to be Jewish and even mark oneself outwardly. Over the years, one began to wonder if this was the nation that survived and recovered from the near annihilation of the Holocaust? Mark does not wave flags, but if the new government begins to treat the Bedouins (for example), he will join the protests even if it puts him at risk himself. If a large part of the democratic population reacts, he will also join in. The blacks in America were not supported by the whites but continued the uprising. He will support.
Mahran says that last Friday he joined the demonstration of the Jewish blacks in Be’er Sheva against their deportation. Loves minority struggles. Not long ago he went to visit a friend in Ra’anana. The friend wrote a book about the Bedouins and mentioned Mahran. The friend spoke of their friendship that would always exist and gave him a copy of the book. Mahran says that we are in the era of the second Israel. I see the hatred in the settlers. The left was silenced, we were defeated. The Arab right (RA’AM) was also defeated. They were silenced. They will work to intensify the hatred in the country. “He” will increase the hatred. The hatred will increase in the south as well. Mahran, perhaps in response to the fear that Rami spoke of, thinks that there is security in the Bedouin settlements. Regarding human rights, Mahran Claims that Arab society is not on the right side and does not yet deserve to wave this flag. Demography, according to him, they won, but the Arabs also did not come out to vote when the left needed them. They entered into apathy caused by the many “beats” they receive from all sides. The classic Bedouin, according to him, Shuts himself down, shy and doesn’t want to intervene. There are fanatics on both sides as in a mirror image. What is there to harm the Bedouin who are also at the bottom. But it is possible that this time the Bedouin will not be silent. In this government “Cahana was right”. The defeat was caused, perhaps, because we fell asleep, perhaps because we were Both the Arabs and the Jews on the left are indifferent.
The coffee is flowing in rounds and we still have some time left. Rami asks the circle “Is a fratricidal war possible”?
Mahran says that we are in transition from democracy to a dictatorship that will lead to a military revolution also with the support of the Arabs. The revolution is designed to restore the tie. Mahran will join the revolution.
Moshe does not expect a civil war to break out in the near future. I do expect that the hatred and violence will intensify. The change we see today is violent and chaotic, not necessarily a fratricidal war. In Argentina there was a military coup, but here it is different. The oppression will be slow and continuous and the citizen alone will understand the spirit of the times. To protect himself and his environment, he will adapt.
Nahshi does not see a scenario of internal war. The people look at what is close to them and are less busy raising their heads for a wider view. That is why they will not rise up but sink in themselves. More and more Israelis will move to other parts of the world. The army will begin to disintegrate little by little. Our sons will not serve for long in an army that does things the opposite of what they learned at home. If there is a non-violent struggle, he participates in it, but he stays away from the events. The country is not ours anymore.
Shmulik remembers that when Cahana arrived in Israel he was in the minority and his party was thrown out of the Knesset. Now his people are in the Knesset and the government. The meeting between us here is not only to drink coffee, it is also to do activities. Every day Shamulik breaks the law and does it knowingly.
I (again Oded) think that people like me will have to make even more difficult decisions. The Palestinians, who are the suffering part of the region, will have their suffering deepen. I have the option of sacrificing my money, my time and my body to alleviate their suffering or to keep these assets and decide that I am protected by my privileges. The confusion will get worse as the gap between the sufferers and the privileged widens. I am again quoting Hillel Cohen, who claims in his book “The Zero Year 1929”, that when there is security tension, each individual gathers under his ethnic affiliation, regardless of his objective position regarding the causes of the conflict. Since I estimate that violence will break out, I want to believe that I will go more with my human justice And not with my ethnic identification.
Rami says he will adapt to the situation. will not endanger himself and his livelihood. Now, he says, it’s theirs. He didn’t like the change in his kibbutz either, but when it happened, he told his children, it’s yours. He himself will not preserve anything. The Bengvirs are legitimate and have won justice and it is theirs. He will only decide about his place, whether here or somewhere else.
Mark claims that there will be no struggle of communities. There will be people who will struggle. The fight has already been decided. Fortunately for the Jewish people, it is divided between Israel and the world. If we was all here, a fratricidal war might have broken out. His children will probably move abroad. There won’t be a violent war and there won’t be a non-violent struggle either. But if there is a clear injustice, and there is an action against it that has a chance of succeeding, he will join.
Mahran comments that the Bedouin who ran over a student in Be’er Sheva this week voted for Likud in the elections (if that makes it any easier for anyone). Mahran comes from the “Ashkenazi” view. Will continue to fight for the country that was. Yes, he says, there will be a civil war here. The Arabs will not join it, but he himself will join the Ashkenazim.
Finishing up.
We are just notifying our many readers that this coming Tuesday 11/29 afternoon we will be hosting a group of religious girls from “Tzali” Preparatory at the Lighthouse. You are all invited.
This time we were: Shmulik, Rami, Mahran, Nahshi, Mark, Moshe, Oded.
Written by: Oded.