Encounter 215 – 22.4.2022

Beneath the eucalyptus tree, which overlooks the plant to the south, sits a couple on “our” chairs. Two pairs of bicycles on the trash can. Nahshi immediately invites for coffee. Enter, arrange a circle and in the process arrive two more cyclists, a father and his 15-year-old son. So it turns out that even before coffee, there is already a “circle”.
Eldor was an army officer and served in the area and this is one perspective he has on Gaza, through the military binoculars and rifle barrel. His second point of view, more compassionate – The situation there is one of helplessness. They gathered there because no one wanted to receive them. There is disregard for Gaza because it is not anyone’s problem.
Louisa comes from Colombia. She speaks English and Spanish and luckily we have Moshe, a native of Argentina who will translate for us and her. Louisa is studying psychology. Colombia has a constant state of internal war because of which other conflicts and external issues are pushed aside. The school has a loose reference to our conflict, but in her opinion it is on a religious rather than a political background.
Segev (15) says that as long as there is no escalation and warming in front of the “Strip”, he does not think about Gaza. If there is warming should respond but not too hard. He knows life there is hard but does not think about it
Honen, Segev’s father, says he has had a long “affair” with Gaza since he was a teenager and visited Khan Yunis. A traumatic visit at the sight of deep poverty. In the army he did a lot with Gaza. In 2014 he was in the area but did not “enter”. Two years ago during the balloon era he was also in “employment.” He has a dream that one day he will return to Gaza and see a different picture from the poor one. His family maintains contact with workers who worked with his father. Dreaming of another reality where he is sitting on the beach in Gaza. Remember them as “wonderful people.”
Shmulik knows Gaza from before. Traveled a lot to the sea and was in contact with workers, a family of Bedouin who were thrown into Gaza in 1953. The border then was a furrow and then a one-wire fence. They worked with him in the barn for many years. Were part of the fabric of life in his place. Knew them from a young age until they became grandparents. These days, a TV show about Israelis evacuation from Sinai at 1982 has been broadcast. Shmulik understands their pain but is also angry at the disregard for the fact that in order to make room for them in an area called the “Yamit region”, hundreds of local farmers who grew vegetables in growing pits were expelled and their growth pits were covered. The cover and deportation that Smulik saw with his own eyes. He says that a state of hopelessness does not lead to a good place, so it is good that workers have recently been allowed to go out to work and earn a living.
Cyclists rush back to Be’eri because the bikes are rented and need to be returned on time.
Rami and Rotem (his son) arrive. Since at the moment the circle contains only “constants” and I know that Rami has arrived for a short time, I ask him to share with us more of his knowledge of our space. Rami chooses to tell about plans he took part in the wake of the Oslo Accords. Plans to develop ties with the Palestinians as part of the agreement. Plans that were “born” following the Oslo Accords and also perished with them.
I will summarize:
In the Oslo Accords, we built a plan for regional cooperation between Israel and the Gaza Strip. They did not talk about “returning territories” but developed models such as the “safe passage” between Gaza and the West Bank, for example. There was a plan for an open canal that included a two-lane road and a train, with passages above it. A second less popular program, was a safe passage as a bridge – an overpass.
There were talks of renewing the railway line through the Erez crossing to Egypt.
A diplomatic crossing into the Gaza Strip was planned in the “Black Arrow” area, near Mefalsim.
The Karni crossing was supposed to be a huge terminal for goods that had even been built, and then dismantled and blown up in 2010.
A huge water reservoir for agriculture in Gaza was planned on the channel of the Besor River, after the Gazans claimed that the Israeli reservoirs along the river deprive them of water for agriculture.
Near Kissufim, on both sides of the border, a large hospital was designed, mainly for maternity.
Near Sufa, a reservoir of aggregates was designed to be transported in long conveyors to the other side, with a magnetic scan that detects metals, so that no weapons would be transferred to them. The planning was not carried out.
Today there is a goods crossing at the Kerem Shalom crossing. It was designed for passenger passage only, also because of the proximity to the airport in Dahania. An airport that has since been bombed and plowed. (Due Diligence: I fantasized about flights from there to Sinai and Europe. Oded.)
These were the plans in the mid-90s of the last century.
Rami and Rotem travel. Tzafrir and Ayala arrive and we continue “circle” after my explanatory remarks.
Moshe shares the feeling of some of us. We are neighbors and my good is related to the good of my neighbors and vice versa. Moshe does not like the term “Gaza Envelope”. This area has value and history. He is afraid like everyone else of the rounds of violence, but at the same time thinks of the Gazans as well.
Ofek came because here he first heard talk in human terms about Gaza. Keeps coming for the same reason.
Omer came for the same reasons that Ofek came. Before getting to know the Lighthouse, he had mostly heard talk of violence in the context of Gaza.
Tzafrir says that Gaza is a very, very difficult sight to face Israel. Familiar with Gaza from other periods. We and the Strip is a vicious circle of a lot of pain. Later, after hearing more people in the circle, Tzafrir said that he suddenly understands the meaning of the question “what is Gaza for you” – suddenly Gaza arouses new thinking in him.
Ayala said that in the kibbutz where she was born and raised, there was a worker from Gaza named Hassona who “managed” all the maintenance on the kibbutz. Her father had a very good relationship with him. Ayala says that during the “rounds” in front of Gaza, she felt real physical pain. Feels “bad” in the sense of state acts being done (also) in her name. It saddens her that something in her was blocked for this pain after more and more rounds.
Jaber recounts the meaning of life in an unrecognized village and also the recognition that there are even those who suffer more. Gaza for him is a common neighbor, space and language. In Gaza, he used to be at sea and sit in restaurants. Jaber is taking a mentoring course. Adds from the knowledge he has acquired about the area in which we are. The factory was established on the plot of Nimer al-Wahidi, he says. A British officer saw sulfur after the First World War, but it was not until the 1930s that land was acquired for the establishment through the mediation of a-Shawa, the mayor of Gaza and its wealth. The plant ceased to operate shortly after the Second World War.
Hanan came because of the kites. Almost 3 years ago there was a kite event and Hanan, who loves and builds kites came because he was upset that the kite was used for inappropriate purposes. On that visit he met us and the rest is history. Later, Hanan created the kite that is placed in the background, inspired by a photograph in which a girl in Gaza is seen painting on a star-shaped wooden board. Hanan loves the conversations on the various topics that they respect, interest and preserve the hope for something good. Gaza is a painful place in our being, he says. We sometimes feel and sometimes ignore. Hanan says that Roni’s operation, during which a piano was transferred for a young man studying music, is a symbol for him. On the one hand a noble act and on the other an inconceivable reality of poverty symbolized by only 2 pianos within a population of over 2 million people. He comes to the “lighthouse” also because in the structure of the circular discourse there is no arguing. Everyone says their opinion without interruption and people come out with a conversational experience.
Mary came following Hanan’s blog. She is here because of the friendliness and listening that is very rare in our places. Gaza is a complexity that attracts it.
Nahshi was born and raised here while it was still possible to meet and meet Gazans. Came to maintain a spark of possibility that would be different. Remember that these are people on both sides who are harmed and disturbed by this situation. He always comes out of here with new insights and a kind of therapy.
We were this time: Eldor, Louisa, Honen, Segev, Hanan, Moshe, Ofek, Omer, Oded, Jaber, Mary, Nahshi, Shmulik, Rami, Rotem, Tzafrir, Ayala.
Wrote: Oded

Encounter 214 – 15.4.2022

Mid-Ramadan, the eve of Passover. Traveling alone to the “lighthouse”.
Muslims fast at home or in shopping malls, Jews gather in the family circle, get ready for the holiday. I drive on the narrow road to our “lighthouse”, between the soft hills, in complete silence. It’s the closest to actually seeing silence physically! I’ll probably be alone, on the eve of a holiday … I’ll sit for a while, have a coffee and offer Rami a little emergence from his illness and sit with me, so we’re both alone in the silence.
Here comes Mark. Drink coffee. Trying to clarify things we talked about last week. Things that got up a bit of an argument and Roni addressed them on WhatsApp which she sent in groups alongside Happy holiday wishes.
Ofek comes. Wearing a supermarket shirt. Because of the holiday he stayed up late working at the branch. He unfolds the subtle way in which the military tries to force him into combat service because of the profile and despite his reluctance.
Comes Maharan and the conversation “flies” to history and cross-religious myths.
A familiar Toyota slides downhill to the development of the structure. There is probably a telepathic coordination between me and Rami.
Neta, Mirale and Rami join. “Just to say hello.” An hour passed exciting. Rami tells us about his physical and spiritual condition. “As Jaber always starts his words” Rami opens and compares himself to Jaber who always starts and tells about the unrecognized villages, “but” compared to Gaza their situation is reasonable … Rami gets up in the morning with a strong sense of “special day”. With such a feeling one should be in the “lighthouse.”
A month passed by him from “Hell.” Stopped treatment for rethinking, recovered a bit, and now has a different direction. This morning, Khaled, a man his age from Gaza who had worked in Be’eri for many years, called him. Rami felt a sense of brotherhood to him. Khaled called to greet Passover. Now Rami is here, at the Lighthouse. Even ready to sip coffee, a drop. Then he asks to do a round of congratulations …
Ofek welcomes the “lighthouse” that has opened up new directions of thinking. He is sure that when faced with challenging situations (in military service?), The things he has absorbed here will help him maintain a proper balance.
Maharan joins in and mentions the “lighthouse” as a place that allows one to express oneself freely even on things that are difficult to hear.
Mark is in his own private circle of thought that is influenced by climatic predictions, definitions of “belonging” and conflict with Jewish-Israeli-Zionist nationalism. More than once, through his thinking and conclusions, they have created a conflict in the “circle”, but today he welcomes the project. Rami smiles.
Mirale (Rami’s mother) and Neta (his sister) mark the project well and of course wish Rami a complete recovery.
I tell Rami that I am missing in the circle with his breadth of knowledge and with his thinking originality. And I note that The Lighthouse has helped me focus on the historical search for the roots of the conflict. I told him that for me, the comparison of his state of health to the state of distress of the Gazans, takes place on the plane of “suffering that you can see but not feel.” Situations that require inconceivable mental strengths for those who (fortunately) have not experienced them.
Rami, Neta and Mirale left. The energies went down a bit and after another round of coffee, we also drove on a road that was now a little less quiet because I continued the conversation with myself.

We were this time: Maharan, Mark, Ofek, Rami, Neta, Mirale, Oded.

Encounter 213 – 8.4.2022

To the place where light is lit, one can navigate hope” Rami once said, defining the meaning of the “lighthouse for the Gaza consciousness.”
Today we came to “turn on a light” with a heavy feeling. The air around us is compressed in a communicative language, in Hebrew. A hegemonic communication that defines the other languages and divides them into dedicated “drawers”. We heard about the political chaos that met with violence between communal and nationalist, and hatred that erupted from all sides everywhere in a language we understand well. No wonder we were enveloped in melancholy.
This is what Roni wrote it in the WhatsApp she sent before she came: “Dear friends, with a heavy heart and a lot of pain, I’ll come today to our lighthouse from which only comes out, even today, the light from which hope can be navigated. In the words of the poet ❤️”.
There are almost no travelers.
In light of all of the above, we gathered today as well as every Friday. The changeable weather brought us back into the building.
Shmulik, Ofek, Roni, Mark, Malki, Oded and in the last half hour also Maharan who claims that the late arrival time is due to the constraints of Ramadan.
Shmulik made coffee.
We talked about different essences. On Judaism, on climate, on the usefulness of wanting to bring about change (can a fly change the trajectory of a nervous elephant?), On Zionism, national rights and also on Gaza, mainly through the information that Roni brings.
Also on resolving the conflict in a Confederate way (the “A Land for All” movement holds a series of Zoom meetings). Mahran also had a short time to review thousands of years of political and historical processes. There is a surprising and interesting originality in his point of view.
We continue to accompany Rami and wish him a speedy and complete recovery.
We were this time: Roni, Maharan, Malki, Ofek, Shmulik, Mark, Oded.
Photographer: Ofek.
Reporter: Oded.

Encounter 212 – 1.4.2022

On the way, Nahshi and I argued, is it already warm and justified enough to move to our summer place, or still continue to congregate inside the building. It was decided for the summer. Pleasant in the shade under the pine trees, the wind is also light and caressing. The “warehouse” of chairs, the one that stores chairs for the summer, has undergone a change. The jamb collapsed! Blocks of stone blocked the entrance. The chairs were not damaged, even for the rusty ones in between.
Ofek, as usual, is already waiting. We introduced him to the summer residence. He came with the guitar. Later he will compose and play to the lyrics of Shmulik, a song about Shmulik’s communist aunt who was cut off from the family in the 1930s. Shmulik was not today (on a trip) to be impressed by the melody and performance, but his sister Hayuta was to get excited in his name as well. The audience also included Nahshi, Moshe and me.
Before and after the song we talked about the last days in the surface and media. There were insights from a television interview with Shaul Arieli and Gideon Levy’s articles in Haaretz.
And what about Gaza?
There was not much to say this week, but the very recurring gathering every week for more than four years is also a statement.
Then Limor arrived armed with a camera and we are already six.
A vehicle passed and its passengers stopped for a moment. They are from Kibbutz Alumim and no, they will not stay for coffee, they are hiking and Shabbat is approaching. But one of them said “You’re the lighthouse right?” We said right and they continued on their way.
At quarter past three Maharan arrived. We immediately pounced on him with (coffee and …) questions about last week in his vicinity. “Look,” he said, “the Arabs were afraid of the Jews and the Jews were afraid of the Arabs, so the malls was deserted.” A kind of economic insight from a seemingly religious community confrontation. Maharan then said that he tried to go on the air on Channel 14 (a “Heritage” channel lol) to tell them “the truth”, but they Ignored him. If so, said Limor, we’ll do a panel simulation now! Maharan was given 2 minutes to tell the “panel” the truth as it is in his opinion. Opinion of a human being, a lawyer, a Bedouin, a Muslim, a native and a resident of the city of Rahat. After the speech was over, Mahran faced “nasty” remarks from the panel that rained down on him. He convinced us, not the panel that remained right.
That is for this week. of course, we send a blessing of recovery to Rami.
We were – Nahshi, Moshe, Hayuta, Ofek, Maharan, Limor, Oded and also Roni, on the phone.
Wrote – Oded.

Encounter 211 – 25.3.2022

After some stormy weather days, the sun in Be’eri shines but the hikers are not. We told ourselves we would be few this time.
But, the circle has its own gravity and it was like this:
We sat Ofek, Mark, Roni, Shmulik and Nahshi, listened to Maya, which came with Roni, hearing her interesting story:
She recently lived in the US, set up and ran a project called “Bead for Peace” a series of creative workshops that bring together Jewish and Muslim women and develop a bond of understanding and tolerance around the bead weaving.
Maya showed us some of the works of her late husband Mori who was an artist and published in the Jerusalem Post works and articles about peace and life in harmony with nature, which sound very relevant today.
Meanwhile, a trio arrived from Modi’in – a mother, daughter and son who were looking for a sulfur factory and found stories about Gaza. They sat fascinated and said that they do not know much about Gaza but are excited to meet such a group. The son said that in his work (medical research) he gets to collaborate with quite a few Arab doctors and friendships are formed between them.
While we are talking about the shocking murder in Be’er Sheva and the horrific reactions in the Israeli media after it, just before Bella, Dina and Malki came from Gvulot – an excited family arrives from the unrecognized beduin village of Alsara. Grandmother, father (physiotherapist who treats people in the Negev region), mother (who was a teacher and is now studying nursing), three cute little children and two other nephews. Despite the difficult atmosphere of the last few days – they decided to come and get to know the people living next to Gaza. Returned from strawberry picking at Yesha and were surprised to find us here. While the children explore the environment, they manage to tell a little about life in an unrecognized village and how to deal with extremism and hatred. Before we parted they invited everyone to be a guest on the family hospitality project “Khan Alsara”.
In the meantime, Limor also arrived and we managed to do one more round about Gaza, inclouding short phone talk to our friend.
before the rain washed everything away and expelled us a little before the planning.
We were this time: Roni, Maya, Ofek, Shmulik, Mark, Nahshi, Bella, Dina, Malki, Rami, Limor, the family from Modi’in and the family from Alsara.
Wrote: Nahshi.

Encounter 210 – 18.3.2022

In the beginning, the country was in chaos, after last week the braces of the table disappeared, today the legs are also missing and a few more chairs have disappeared.
But the wind of the lighthouse hovers over the surface of the site, and there is light. And Nahshi said, Let there be coffee, and he will distinguish between coffee and tea. And Shmulik saw that it was good and blessed a pretzel.
And then Ofek shall grow, a righteous man from Mabu’ym, and with him a stringed instrument, and this is the psalm (lyrics by Shmulik, melody of Ofek):
“In front of the wall of the west wall
Facing the holy ark
Standing a child carrying his eyes
And will not know the secrets of the wall… “
And while the melody and the coffee (first round) Roni appeared with pastries.
Meeting 210 of the lighthouse set a world record, not in the number of hikers who visited the place, but in the number of times the “circle” was opened:
With a group of students from Ben Gurion University,
And a kind couple from Hod Hasharon,
And families of Yoshivya,
And between rounds, between tea and coffee, Ofek (who will celebrate 18 this week) informed us about his placement in the IDF, and promised to continue with us every Friday and bring the lighthouse massege to the consciousness of many young people.
Ah! There was another exciting moment: Roni’s phone rang and we expected the sound of the brothers across the fence, but the British did not install an antenna in the sulfur factory and we did not hear a word…
And for anyone who cares about keeping the lighthouse doctrine: We managed to get home just in time for Shabbat. Next week will be easier because of the Daylight saving time.
Blessing of Ramadan Karim, in the hope of peace and brotherhood in the Gaza Strip, Ukraine, and all over the world.
We were this time: Roni, Ofek, Shmulik, Nahshi, Moshe and hikers as above.
Wrote: Moshe.
Fill in the blanks: Nahshi, who also managed to photograph, make coffee and improvise a table.

Encounter 209 – 11.3.2022

Since the outbreak of anemone blossoms and the waves of hikers who visited the reserve (and of course the sulfur plant site), we have witnessed extensive use of the chairs we have brought in favor of the “circle”. This in itself is not problematic, also leaving the chairs scattered inside the factory space is not problematic… The “problem” begins when we have to collect those who are taken and left far away. Herds of sheep were also brought in during this period to lick the green grass before it would turn yellow and dry up (and there would be combustible material in the fires). The loving shepherds take the chairs under a tree and sit with the herd. Then they “forget” to return the chairs. This time, in addition to all this, the braces of the table disappeared and only the “legs” were left… We searched and searched but in vain (at least we collected dirt during the scans).
So we arranged the refreshments on four chairs. We did not have high expectations on this cold rainy day.
As usual in the last three months, Ofek comes first. Shmulik and I collect Hayuta and come and Roni arrives too.
After we finished collecting chairs in the area, we sat down with coffee and talked about this and that and the world immersed in its wars.
When Amit, Ido and Rossana arrived, we opened a circle.
Later, Mark, Nomika, Rami and Naomi will join, and just before the final, a group of 40 Jerusalem retirees.
Amit recounts a visit to Gaza in 1998 with Meron Benvenisti and General Nasser Yosef to promote the idea of a binational state. A call from Arafat to Nasser Yusuf took him out of the meeting and it ended in nothing. Amit remembers the people in Gaza better and warmer than the people in the West Bank. They have an “internal heat,” she says. Wrong decisions in the management of the conflict and especially in the decision to hold elections in Gaza and the West Bank at 2006 have, in her opinion, led to an escalation. There were those who said that the Palestinians are unfamiliar with the democratic system and that it is too sharp a transition in the process of running such a scattered community and without real territory and rule. There were elections anyway and Hamas received permission to participate even though it did not accept the Oslo Accords.
Ronny talked about the conference we held at Sderot last week. She got excited at the conference and kept thinking about it even after that. Suddenly the Palestinian Jewish connection seems very natural and true. It was so normal! Yes you can get along and you can feel normal.
As usual, she talked to Rami this week. He is waiting to meet with us. In the meantime he met with others.
Mark, when he came to Israel 40 years ago, was first and foremost engaged in “placing” himself in Israel. From the moment he arrived he settled in this area. He then began to engage in socio-political activity. Driven more by feelings and less by information. “We live in a time of very tough politics,” he states. There is no empathy so it is difficult for him to see the light at the end of the tunnel. It is hard for him to get excited about good deeds here and there because the despair is great. Regarding Gaza – he has lived by her side since arriving in Israel. His children, who were born here, will not return to live here, in this area. They also have a hard time hearing him speak out against Zionism. In the last five years he can already clearly say that he is not a Zionist. It’s hard for him to say his opinion inside the house, not wanting to hear it. Now that everything is quiet, it is easy to forget the fact that the silence is tense. He has reading problems and therefore has difficulty acquiring information and communication is unreliable. He has a hard time with the fact that the world is excited about Ukrainian refugees and not African or Middle Eastern refugees.
Rossana, coming from the center. She has not had any contact with Gazans in the past. In general, Gaza is a painful wound, and when a part of the body hurts, the whole body hurts. As long as there are people under our occupation and control, it hurts with us too. Pain is not always treated and that is why she came here today, to the “lighthouse”. Not a Zionist and did not served the army. She has an activist past. Did an alternate service. She had an unsuccessful attempt with a group of people, Jews and Arabs, to build a life together. Traveled to Tamera (Portugal) to learn about how to do it right. They returned to Israel, lived together and were supposed to move to a farm in the south, but the group disbanded. She had a Palestinian partner who returned to Portugal for Tamera, he does not want to be here. Currently less active in peace and more in the climate crisis. Feels she has no enemies and she is not afraid. Do not want to be an occupier even with that means maybe she is not from this nation.
Ido comes here and admits to his shame that he came because of what is happening in Europe. Ramy once said in our circle that the greater the darkness, the brighter the light of the lighthouse. Ido should see the darkness in his eyes. At the conference he sat and listened with tears in his eyes. Was excited to hear people who are able to see evil and face it. Met Rossana in Portugal. Ido is a second and third generation Holocaust survivor and lives in a sense of disaster all the time. He wants to live a normal life, it’s a daily struggle for him. Come here to connect. Looking at Gaza and trying to get into their shoes, hearing evidence. Under a tyrannical regime, even democracy fails to function. We have some rest from Netanyahu’s rule of darkness, they do not have it with Hamas.
Hayuta sympathizes with Rossana’s words about the pain in the body. That is why our democracy is sick. She lives here mainly to strengthen her life and give them meaning.
Ofek says “Gaza is curiosity.” To him, Gaza is a box of cookies on a high shelf and he, the little boy, wants cookies but can not come. When he hears in a circle the “old men” tell of the experience of getting to know the Gaza of yesteryear he is jealous. “It’s not fair,” he says, “that you won and I did not.”
Nomika connects to Mark’s pessimism. She, too, like Roni, witnessed the euphoria that prevailed at the conference. Brotherhood and solidarity. Needless to say (I am allowed …) that Nomika was the main organizer and leader of the conference! Unfortunately, due to high translation costs, the conference “spoke” Hebrew only. Next time we will get better. Glad the “Desert Stars” arrived and also a bus with women from Eilabun. Jaber was also amazing in what he said and in helping during the conference. Nomika is in other groups and is exposed to difficult and oppressive daily information about the events of the occupation.
She wants to read a song by Yehuda Amichai, “The third song is about Dickie”, but a tour guide with 40 Jerusalem pensioners appears in the doorway. Since it’s a quarter to four and the cold is starting to bother me, Ramy signals for me to “take” the team. The guide (Zohar) gathers the group and tells them something like “We do have a plan, but we came across an interesting phenomenon of a group of residents here and we should listen to them. Please encourage.”
I explain the factory and its history, the buildings next to it and continue with an explanation of the “lighthouse”, the idea and the deed. Answers questions and the guide concludes and invites everyone back to the bus. We also fold equipment and disperse.
It should be noted the role of Shmulik who successfully filled Nahshi’s place in the preparation of coffee and tea.
We were: Roni, Shmulik, Hayuta, Oded, Ofek, Mark, Nomika, Ido, Amit, Rossana, Rami, Naomi, Zohar and the 40 pensioners.
Photographer: Ofek. Wrote: Oded.

Encounter 208 – 4.3.2022

It may be possible to detect an increasing trend of spreading the gospel of the lighthouse and the consciousness. Because even today and for several weeks now, arriving at the meeting at the lighthouse is like a rising spring.
This time, the pioneers holding Ofek and I lined up at the lighthouse.
At the same time, words and voices were said at a conference of “Bringing Peace Back to the Discourse” that took place in the community of Ibim – where Oded and Jaber spoke about our Lighthouse. Here is a link to a selection of excerpts from the conference.
So we prepared the circle and the table
And we waited…
And we waited…
And we called to passers-by who passed us pedaling and wandering,
Finally some came and wanted to stay with us for a while – 3 pedal families from the north to whom Ofek explained our essence and even guided them on the hidden attractions – for example a well 51 meters deep!
Itzik from Usha was more deeply interested, and when the rest flocked to peek at the well, he stayed to ask questions. On the value of caring for others in particular. He said, Quoted: “My world is as narrow as an ant’s world” His acquaintance with Gaza is from the 1970’s and from the aspect of the reserve service there only. After they left, Itzik from Be’eri and two from Nir Akiva arrived. Itzik said he heard stories from people from Be’eri who were in Gaza and were in daily friendships with the Gazans. To him it sounded like a fantasy. They – the Gazans under a regime that does them harm. Shani said that as a child she had a Gaza escort who would accompany her to kindergarten and school.
Then Ramy appeared in a storm in his white car as a knight’s horse, with reinforcements of ashes, kettles, and spoons that helped withstand the onslaught of the influx that followed.
Noa Galili from “Gisha”, Roni, Malki, and also Limor, Dina and Hanan joined in with reinforcements for the rapprochement. Close up starred a marvelous dish in his taste made by Hanan to boast, leaves to enrich the tea brought by Dina and more.
With his familiar skill, Rami created the framework of the discourse (here is a link to his words) which therefore allowed Noa Galili to represent the Gisha organization. Here is a link to her words.
Thanks to Rami’s experienced skill, it was possible to “stream” the many groups of participants in order to make room for those who came after, and in order for the Gaza consciousness to form and permeate comfortably.
Of course, under the constraint of multiple participants and their stressful schedules, a discontinuous cycle of “tasting” of opinions was created and not everyone could be heard.
So the experienced team worked together to advance the issue: Hanan opened circles and told the story of the lighthouse group, Rami added and then led on to an illustrated tutorial about the lighthouse and Roni presented the groups with the stories and her work as an example of possible action.
Limor constantly flowed the glasses she cleaned in Sisyphean cycles and Dina willingly assisted like a skilled waitress and directed the requests for coffee, tea or both.
Then finally we were joined by Oded, Moshe and Nahshi who returned from the arena of an enemy conference and recounted experiences.
We finished late because it was so pleasant together that we did not feel like going.
We were: dozens of visitors, including Itamar, Itzik and their families from the north, Itzik from Be’eri, Shani from Nir Akiva, the Ofek group: Omer, Yogev, and Oran. Roni, Rami, Nahshi, Hanan, Limor, Malki, Anat, Uzi, Moshe, Rami’s sister,
Registered in collaboration with Ofek, Mary.

Encounter 207 – 25.2.2022

Usually, in the summaries I write, I try to quote a statement from everyone who participates in the “circle”. not today. Today many guests came to the “lighthouse”, probably 50 or so…
A group of hikers arrived who were led by a current tour guide known as “Yoram”, but in the past, in his military service, was called “Sherman”. Sherman and I (“Bachar” as I was called then) were in the army together 50 years ago. Today Sherman led a group of about 25 hikers to our “lighthouse”.
At the same time, we celebrated Ronny’s birthday today. In honor of the lighthouse’s first lady’s birthday, her family members came and friends from the area also came. Of course, everyone knows that if you want to “catch” Roni on Friday, you have to get to the “lighthouse”, While a birthday ceremony was being held for Roni and Shmulik dedicated a song by him, I gave the group of travelers a tour and an explanation (all I learned from Rami) about the factory and its surroundings. At the end of the tour we got in and joined the circle. There I continued to tell about the “lighthouse.”
We started a “circle” and Roni told about the moment when she realized that she was not alone here… that there would be another community of people, another people who also claim their rights and space. She came to this insight while she was with her family on her husband’s agricultural mission in Egypt, after the outbreak of peace…
There, in Cairo, she met a Palestinian family through the friendship formed between her daughter, who was 6 at the time, and the Palestinian girl. Unlike in children, the acquaintance between the parents was not easy, but when the “boycott” wall was broken and ties were formed, she realized that people belong to their place of birth. In time, she read, heard, became interested and expanded her consciousness about the other people, the Palestinian people. She understood the immense power of dialogue as a force that thaws hostility and brings people closer together. “How many times can you go in with your head against the wall and not look for a detour,” says Roni in the context of more and more rounds of violence in the area. “No I am the one who dreams” she says, dreamers are those on both sides who think the other side can be hidden. The more she knows, the more she realizes that there is someone to talk to.
We then tried to start an orderly “circle”, but the group leaders wanted to continue the trip. A kind of “rebellion” began in the group, there were those for whom it was important to stay and express themselves. The group stayed a little longer. Most of the group and a large part of the other guests did not speak so the list of names that will appear at the end of the summary will be very partial.
Amit very much appreciates Roni’s words, but needs to know the reality. Amit works at the Technion and was on a team that tried to persuade the Ministry of Defense to open a floating port in Gaza. Be nice, they will have a port, they will not be nice, we will harness the port to the ship and drag it to Ashdod… he think such meetings are a nice thing, but “should be realistic”, with all due respect to citizens’ dialogue initiatives, the arrangements are made by governments.
Hannah thinks dialogue is important and what politicians do is for their survival needs.
Smadar says people want to live and need to get to a point where they have good reasons to keep what they have in life.
Nimrod works at the Technion. There are many Arab colleagues at the Technion. In recent years there has been an interesting development of collaborations between Arab and Jewish students. Global problems, he says, are not solved in personal discourse but only through leaders.
Amos works at a bank. A few years ago they merged with an Arab bank. He is under the impression that the Arabs who work for them want a solution, but thinks like Nimrod that the leaders are solving the big problems.
Hagar was much involved in joint activities. Agrees that the solution should come from “above”. But it’s important that we break through the barrier by dialogue, like what we do here at Lighthouse. Increase meetings and joint activities. Hagar did a workshop in Jisr a-Zarqa and someone told her that he suddenly found out that there were nice Jews…
Sefi told about the conference we are holding next week and he intends to come to it. Sefi tells about an association he founded, “Sipur-Hikaya“, An organization that aims to expose as many Israelis to the Palestinian narrative as possible and as many Palestinians as possible to the Jewish-Israeli narrative. A mass of pressure from citizens needs to be created. Make leaders step out of their comfort zone that is not changing anything. If the leaders initiate any change and the move does not succeed, their political careers will be damaged. That’s why they prefer to do a lot of nothing. Lateral pressure from below can spur them into action.
Afterwards, the group members got up to continue on their way, but since some of them still had questions and a desire to express themselves, small standing groups were formed on the way out. In the midst of all this mingling, those present gradually dispersed until around three-thirty, only the “regulars” remained. We took advantage of the time left to talk about our assessments, of the “lighthouse” for the conference. Meanwhile, Rami called Ronnie to wish her a happy birthday and of course we were happy to meet him even if only on Skype.
This is for today. The list of participants will include all those I have identified by name, and will therefore be very partial: Shmulik, Roni, Ofek, Omer, Mary, Ovadia, Michal, Mirhaleh, Neta, Ilan, Rami, Sefi, Amos, Amit, Hagar, Hanna, Nimrod, Yoram, Oded.
Wrote: Oded.

Encounter 206 – 18.2.2022

A sunny Friday, Be’eri Reserve abounds in bloom and hikers. The surroundings of the “lighthouse” are buzzing with people on bicycles, vehicles and legs. Just pick and order, crowds abound, reach out and touch them.
First group joins: Families, parents and children.
My introductory “speech” and Ofek after me.
Ofek says he came because here he hears the words from the “people” and not from the leaders in their media language. He only heard about Gaza from stories of those who were there. He also hopes to be there.
Hayuta here to say that human beings are equal and the value of man, as far as he is human, is the same.
For Nahshi, Gaza’ns are people he knows. Gaza is close in sight and touch. It seems delusional, so close and impossible to help and communicate with each other. The disconnect is terrible. Come to remind himself that this is not normal and there will be better days.
Moshe prefers to define himself as a resident of the area. Occasionally comes to the “lighthouse”, because here, in talks with Gaza, understandings and agreements of basic human values are formed.
Margalit says that they, there in Gaza, are human beings but are controlled by a terrorist organization and they are against us. She asks us what we think our side should do … After all, we are the ones who experience the “not nice” side of the Gazans.
Noa, stumbled upon …
When Roni learned to drive, she did so naturally in the city closest to her place of residence, in Rafah… Roni lived close to the Gaza Strip, and “lived in Gaza.” This is a mission for her to pass on information about Gaza. It is important to Roni that we know and live with the neighbors. When the Gazans realize they have support, it will be better. Tells about Rami Kleinstein’s show in the war in 2014 during which she received a phone call from a friend in Gaza who was worried about her safety due to a missile that fell near her home, heared the noise of helicopters in the air and thought of her Gazan friend who has no protection at all… Out of this situation came an article that was broadcast on television, in which the Gazan friend told the reporter and Roni “You’re there and we’re here. Nobody’s going anywhere. Think of us too.”
Shmulik always comes and says that to a certain extent, this is a conscientious objector … knows that for friends on the other side who know about us, it is important to know that we are here. For them, much more than for us, it takes courage to develop contact with Israelis.
Yiftach says everyone wants peace. He wonders if on the other side there is an openness like ours…
Or introduces and says that it is very beautiful what is happening here, in the “lighthouse”. The direction in which things have turned in the last 15 years has greatly surprised him. He is discouraged by the “story”, it is nice to see hope “in you” he concludes.
Haim is one of those children, their mother told them that when they grow up they will not go to the army because there will be no need for an army when there is peace … Haim can understand that in Gaza and the West Bank they do not want to see us here. He is skeptical. Do not believe that such an initiative, like the “lighthouse”, will do anything.
As mentioned, we hosted families and had children as well. When their parents wanted to continue the trip, Ofir, a 10-year-old girl, asked to say something.
Ophir said that if everyone does something for someone else it will be better!
These go and others come, sit down and treat themselves to coffee. And as usual, I introduce us…
Shmulik says that we are sitting, talking and hoping that the wound will heal (the conflict…). Today, he says, workers are moving to Israel and there is employment. It’s really a rescue for them.
Ramy says that when he was a child, he walked to the border with the Strip. They, the children, went to the border and waved to the workers who worked in the fields. After the war they visited there. As an adult, he told his children that he did not engage in hatred. We sit here out of a choice of love. Ramy has no doubt that in love we will reach a better place. When we speak about Gaza, we tell each other that it is a temporary matter and we will meet soon …
Roni talks about the connections she creates between young people in Israel and Gaza. Our circle of friends there is growing, she says. When she receives pictures from Gaza of happy children, for example when they received new schoolbags for school (with the help of donations from Israelis), it gives her hope.
Ella is 13 years old and the word “Gaza” reminds her of Hamas.
Maya says we are in a different reality and fed on the media that portrays Gaza in a negative way. When she pauses to think, she realizes that under Hamas the situation there is bleak and difficult. She listened to those who spoke before her and said we had renewed things she did not know before.
Yelena says they live far from the Strip and understand that for us, the closer ones, it is different. For her, Gaza is what the media says …
Oleg came to Israel in 1990. Two years later he had already served in the Gaza Strip. There he first met Gaza. There were two Jewish families who lived in Rafah Yam and did not talk to each other … the soldiers took care of them. The sight of crabs coming out en masse from the sea, at four in the morning, reminded him of National Geographic… The image of Gaza today is hungry and poor with bad rulers. The communities in the area suffer from shelling and he identifies with us more than with them. A different attitude towards Gaza could have brought a lot of tourists and prosperity.
Moshe studied here, at the “Lighthouse”, That there 2 million inhabitants in Gaza and only 2 pianos … one of them is a gift from Roni. Tells the history of the kite that is permanently placed as part of the circle scenery.
Hayuta lives close to the strip and hears the muezzin calls. Sometimes we are asked, what exactly can be done? … Well, Hayuta believes that words have power. Doing nothing is a convenient option. Also – just “talking about” it’s empowering.
Ofer says that Gaza is part of the Land of Israel in its various components. Defines himself as a man of peace and asks what they are willing to do to change their bitter fate… they are apathetic to a government that abuses them.
Elizabeth says that “once Gaza was Gaza” is no longer today.
Shlomi says it takes two for tango. If there is no desire on the other hand, our humanity will not help.
Meir thinks that collaborations between groups, rather than between individuals, can create an effect. Where is the group there, on the other side, which acts like you? he asks…
Irit believes in win-win. To achieve the result requires effort on both sides. If there is a will on both sides it will be possible to achieve wonderful things. Realizes there are some “buds” on the other side but not developed enough.
For Ilana, “Gaza is Trouble”! I do not know how to get out of it … She feels as if there is no desire for change in Gaza but she lives far away and not really informed… Hope it will be good.
Groups change again
Itzik says that today, Gaza is a bone in the throat. Served a lot of reservists in Gaza. Once upon a time, at first, it was like a trip … he did car treatments in a garage in Gaza … today he feels like the people who spoke before him. We, he adds, have a tendency to help them but they are not a serious partner. We try, but they are not interested in contacting us. Hears that their goal, to eliminate us. He’s not convinced it’s true and pretty much wonders where the truth is.
Ruthie has a love for human beings on the one hand, and fear on the other. Rounds of violence.
Judah says the situation in Gaza serves the rulers of both sides. Without governments the residents would have gotten along just fine.
Rachel takes care of us. It does not seem to her that we are sitting comfortably here. Gaza for her is the people who suffer with us …
Yona was a rookie soldier in 1967 serving in the area and was afraid of being killed.
David opposes the use of the word “they”. The residents and the government should be separated. The question is, how much do we help ordinary citizens to express themselves in front of the rulers, with us and with them.
Ronny explains the point that needs to start from somewhere. Tells about groups of teenagers on both sides she meets. About the desire to look ahead and work together. Tells about a celebration of International Peace Day three years ago and how they celebrated simultaneously on both sides of the fence. Feels like she’s the voice of Gaza. Not a sound of misery, she says, but a cry that expresses hope. Do not believe that in Gaza there is someone, even the worst, who really thinks we can be thrown into the sea …
Then we talked to Rami, he feels safe now where he is. Looking for partners for Palestinian and Israeli initiatives, another initiative such as the schoolbags operation. Leave Gaza for a short time and will come back stronger. Think the circle of activists can be expanded. Wants to be listened to.
That is, the south returns to the north and the red remains.
Partial list of participants:
Nahshi, Roni, Ofek, Shmulik, Maharan, Jaber, Oded, Rami, Rami, Hayuta, Moshe, Mary, Margalit, Noa, Yiftach, Or, Haim, Ofir (and 6 other girls and boys who did not speak or say names), Ella, Maya, Yelena, Oleg, Ofer, Elizabeth, Shlomi, Meir, Irit, Ilana, Itzik, Ruthie, Yehuda, Rachel, Yona, David.
Wrote: Oded